5 Best Sandwich Shops in Indianapolis🥇

5 Best Sandwich Shops in Indianapolis
Delectable sandwich. Source: Pexels

Below is a list of the top and leading Sandwich Shops in Indianapolis. To help you find the best Sandwich Shops located near you in Indianapolis, we put together our own list based on this rating points list.

Indianapolis Best Sandwich Shops:

The top rated Sandwich Shops in Indianapolis are:

  • Subito – ensures that every detail is taken care of
  • Goose The Market – is made around the love of remarkable food
  • Bbi Cafe & Sandwich Shop – is using the finest ingredients
  • Jersey Mike’s Subs – offers high-quality meats and cheese sliced in front of you
  • Shapiro’s Delicatessen – serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner daily

Subito

Subito
Subito. Source: Screenshot from www.subitosoups.com

Subito proudly sources their ingredients from local purveyors and starts every day by baking its signature Garda rolls in-house. All of its meal items have been created by the Subito team and they work hard to make sure that every detail is taken care of, both in the preparation and execution of the final product. The soup selection rotates daily and they have sandwich specials often.

With several options created with business meetings in mind, Subito is pleased to provide a fresh and healthy lunch option for you and your team. Based on its in-house menu, they will partner with you to create a meal fitting for a lunch meeting or special celebration.

Products/Services:

Sandwiches, Salads, Soup, Catering

LOCATION:

Address: 44 Virginia Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Phone: 
(317) 220-8211
Website:
www.subitosoups.com

REVIEWS:

“If you want to have an amazing lunch and spend under $15 – this is the place to go. You can’t sit inside, but you can walk to Monument Circle and sit on the steps and enjoy your food. Or any of the downtown parks. My favorite menu item is Walla Walla and my coworkers always get lobster bisque here – it’s delicious based on their satisfied faces and habitual returns to Subito. I can’t wait till they open a legit Italian restaurant in Indy!” – Hale S.

Goose The Market

Source: Pexels
Source: Pexels

Goose The Market is made around the love of remarkable food. The people who passionately produce it, and the rest of them who can’t wait to get their hands on it. You can expect inside Goose The Market is their daily selection of sandwiches, soups, gelato, and small plates, cut-to-order beef, pork, poultry, and game from small Indiana farms raising their animals on pasture. They also offer craft beer and wine by the bottles to take home.

Products/Services:

Sandwiches, Soup, Events, Order Online, Catering, Reservations

LOCATION:

Address: 2503 N Delaware St, Indianapolis, IN 46205
Phone: 
(317) 924-4944
Website:
www.goosethemarket.com

REVIEWS:

“Very smart staff with great recommendations. High-quality products – both what they make and what they source to sell. Don’t miss the basement where the beer and wine live.” – Noah M.

Bbi Cafe & Sandwich Shop

Bbi Cafe & Sandwich Shop
Bbi Cafe & Sandwich Shop. Source: Screenshot from www.bbicafe.net

Bbi Cafe & Sandwich Shop‘s food is prepared fresh using the finest ingredients, and its goal is to not only feed you but to delight you. For over 15 years Bbi Cafe & Sandwich Shop has served Indy’s Northwest. Purchased in 2012 by Amin & Nancy Abdelhaq, the cafe has been remodeled and the menu updated. With Amin’s background in Mediterranian cooking and Nancy’s Mexican cuisine and both chefs grounded in American favorites, you will find the selections tasty and delicious.

Products/Services:

Breakfast, Lunch, Catering

LOCATION:

Address: 4825 Oakbrook Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
Phone: 
(317) 280-1004
Website:
www.bbicafe.net

REVIEWS:

“Amazing food. always have a special.” – Mark G.

Jersey Mike’s Subs

Jersey Mike's Subs
Jersey Mike’s Subs. Source: Screenshot from www.jerseymikes.com

Jersey Mike’s Subs offers high-quality meats and cheese sliced in front of you, store baked bread, and the authentic taste – served Mike’s Way, fresh lettuce, onions, tomatoes, oil, vinegar, and spices. And everything is served with a smile. Jersey Mike’s catering is sure to please, choose from the subs by the box, subs by the bag or personal boxed lunches, and dessert. Jersey Mike’s Subs cookie and brownie trays are the perfect finales to any type of gathering.

Products/Services:

Cold Subs, Hot Subs, Kid’s Meal, Sides, Drinks, Desserts, Catering, Breakfast

LOCATION:

Address: 5025 E 82nd St #1700, Indianapolis, IN 46250
Phone: 
(317) 595-9993
Website:
www.jerseymikes.com

REVIEWS:

“Quick, friendly service and an excellent, fresh-made sub!” – Kent F.

Shapiro’s Delicatessen

Shapiro's Delicatessen
Shapiro’s Delicatessen. Source: Screenshot from www.shapiros.com

Shapiro’s Delicatessen is owned and managed by one family for over 110 years, Shapiro’s kosher-style Delicatessen is an Indianapolis institution. Famous for the piled-high sandwiches, its meats (corned beef, pastrami, brisket) are still slow-cooked in-store. Its homemade dishes like macaroni and cheese and matzo ball soup are second to none.

Shapiro’s incredible cheesecakes, delicious rye bread, New York-style bagels, and delectable desserts keep Indianapolis residents and visitors coming back for more. Breakfast, lunch, and dinner served daily.

Products/Services:

Sandwiches, Dessert, Entrees, Salads & Platters, Soup & Stew, Sides, Children’s Menu, Bagels & Bread, Drinks, Sharipo’s Marketplace, Catering

LOCATION:

Address: 808 S Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN 46225
Phone: 
(317) 631-4041
Website:
www.shapiros.com

REVIEWS:

“Pastrami sandwich was awesome! And all the sweets look amazing. Have to get one next time.” – Tyler W.