5 Best Supermarkets in New York 🥇

5 Best Supermarkets in New York

Below is a list of the top and leading Supermarkets in New York. To help you find the best Supermarkets located near you in New York, we put together our own list based on this rating points list.

New York’s Best Supermarkets:

The top-rated Supermarkets in New York are:

  • Morton Williams Supermarkets – supermarket chain stocking meats, seafood & baked goods along with name-brand dry goods.
  • Key Food Supermarkets – chain offering groceries & general merchandise, such as cleaning supplies & beauty products.
  • Fairway Market 74th Street – grab-and-go selection of upscale prepared foods attached to a sprawling gourmet grocery store.
  • D’Agostino – family-owned supermarket chain stocking basics & some well-known NY brands.
  • Westside Market – local-feeling 24/7 market stocking everything from meat & produce to gourmet & prepared foods.

Morton Williams Supermarkets

Best Supermarkets in New York

Morton Williams Supermarkets is a long-standing, family-owned grocery chain in New York City that was founded in 1952. It features ShopRite, its private-label brand that is supplied by Wakefern Food Corporation, ShopRite’s parent company. Morton Williams’ first store opened in the Bronx and was originally operated under the Associated Supermarkets brand. The chain has 14 supermarkets in Manhattan as well as one in Jersey City. They also own two liquor stores running under the name Morton Williams Wine & Spirits, which are independently owned separate from the chain grocery stores.

Products/Services:
Online shopping, weekly specials, catering.

LOCATION:
Address: East 87th Street, 1211 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10128
Phone: (212) 722-0229
Website: mortonwilliams.com

REVIEWS:
Great customer service. Nice selection of Kosher items in all departments including chicken/meat. – Rachel Oppenheim

Key Food Supermarkets

Best Supermarkets in New York City

Key Food Supermarkets has been providing quality fresh food products since the late 30s in Brooklyn when a few grocery store owners decided to band together to make a cooperative that has branches in New York, New Jersey, Florida, Pennsylvania, Connecticut, and Massachusetts. Key Foods’ HQ is located in Staten Island, and also operates under the Key Food Marketplace, Key Fresh & Natural, Food Dynasty, Urban Market, Food World, and SuperFresh banners.

Products/Services:
Grocery, online shopping, gift cards, club card.

LOCATION:
Address: 52 Avenue A, New York, NY 10009
Phone: (212) 477-9063
Website: keyfood.com/store

REVIEWS:
Been going there for 21 years now always enjoy the people and some of the cashiers. Lol. Overall a nice market especially if the people know you. – Tati Kelly

Fairway Market 74th Street

Best Supermarkets in NYC

Fairway Market 74th Street is a grocery chain that was founded in 1933, expanding in the New York area with 15 grocery stores and 4 liquor stores within the tri-state area as of 2018. The grocery chain’s vision is to ensure that every food item customer brings home is the freshest and the best quality, thus focusing on obtaining only the best and freshest products available. Another highlight of Fairway is its donations of food to local food banks like the Food Bank For New York City where they feed people in need. The chain has also made a tradition of donating food during holidays, especially Thanksgiving where they provide meals to the less fortunate.

Products/Services:
Organic food, fresh produce, packaged foods, baked goods, virtual cooking classes.

LOCATION:
Address: 2121 Broadway, New York, NY 10023
Phone: (212) 994-9555
Website: fairwaymarket.com/74thstreetcafe

REVIEWS:
The best selection of organic food I. A non all health food store. Has other produce and fresh and packaged foods. Baked goods by Fairway included. Manned fish and meat departments. Currently, open 24 hours/ 7 days per week – Bernard Cohen

D’Agostino

New York Best Supermarkets

D’Agostino is a family-owned supermarket chain founded in 1932 by D’Agostino brothers Nicola and Pasquale. The D’Agostino brothers were one of the proponents during the start of the supermarket industry. D’Agostino has had the slogan ‘New York’s Grocer’ and has appeared in entertainment media to showcase New York’s city setting. They have appeared on both the big and small screen on films and television shows like Death Wish, The Prisoner of Second Avenue, Will & Grace, Friends, and American Psycho.

Products/Services:
Grocery, home delivery, store pickup, online shopping.

LOCATION:
Address: 1074 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10021
Phone: (212) 988-8813
Website: dagnyc.com

REVIEWS:
The staff there at that location are knowledgeable courteous and kind and always have a smile thanks it’s a pleasure going there. – Will SegArra

Westside Market

NYC Best Supermarkets

Westside Market is considered as one of the best food markets in a sea of quality food markets in New York. They have an emphasis on love for what they do, their service to their customers, and having a keen focus on quality products and customer experience. They have a wide selection of quality and fresh fruits and vegetables, meats, and cheese. They also offer a good selection of prepared food like sandwiches and salads; these elements along with ana amazing staff who are professional to the core make Westside Market one of the best sources of food and groceries in New York.

Products/Services:
Online ordering, delivery, fresh produce, imported foods, homemade foods.

LOCATION:
Address: 2840 Broadway, New York, NY 10025, United States
Phone: (212) 222-3367
Website: wmarketnyc.com

REVIEWS:
Westside Market is always the place to go for great cheese, and if you don’t feel like cooking, there’s a variety of ready-made stuff to choose from. – Elizabeth Nicome