5 Best Stationery Stores in New York 🥇

Best Stationery Stores in New York

Below is a list of the top and leading Stationery Stores in New York. To help you find the best Stationery Stores located near you in New York, we put together our own list based on this rating points list.

New York’s Best Stationery Stores:

The top rated Stationery Stores in New York are:

  • Gift Man – a 35-year old family business in Brooklyn
  • Bowne & Co. – New York’s oldest operating business
  • Greenwich Letterpress – a sister-owned company
  • Paper Source – innovates hundreds of stationery items
  • Stationery and Toy World – your one-stop-shop for all your stationery and toy needs

Gift Man

gift man new york

Gift Man Gifts and Souvenir Shop is a 35-year old stationery store in Brooklyn. It’s one of the most enjoyable gifts and souvenir shops in the community. Once you enter its doors, you will be greeted by the smell of candles, scented oils, and incense that will definitely enhance your shopping experience.

You may find a large collection of vintage license plats from every state and every year. If you want jewelry, they prefer jewelry, they have small sterling silver and precious stones. Imported Japanese dolls, t-shirts, and other merchandise may be found in this special shop.


Stationery, Jewelry, Vintage Items, Clothing


Address: 176 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11217
Phone: (718) 499 0721
Website: giftmangifts.com


“This shop is great, They sell lots of New York and Brooklyn related gifts but also a ton of other random stuff too. The prices for their souvenirs were really affordable compared to the souvenir shops in Manhattan hey sell shirts, kids’ toys, Russian nesting dolls, baby clothes, pens, magnets, books, jewelry and much more. They open pretty late on a Sunday too so it’s a good spot to check out if you want unique gifts later at night.” – Magdalena Russo

Bowne & Co.

bowne & co. store

Bowne & Co. go way back to 1900. They supplied printed materials for conducting business, which eventually caused the demand for stationery, invoices, and other printed materials. They are also widely known for its letterpress printing services, which you may avail of after setting up an appointment.

You may intrigue yourself with letterpress workshops as well. Printing Workshops use these traditional methods and historical presses that were used for documentation purposes back in the day. A workshop may take as long as 3.5 hours. You will receive printed items from these workshops that you may display at home.


Stationery, Letterpress Workshops, Journals


Address: 211 Water St, New York, NY 10038
Phone: (646) 315 4478
Website: southstreetseaportmuseum.org


“Large selection of unique stationery, journals, and small gifts. There’s also working antique printing presses in the rear of the store. It’s the oldest business in NYC operating under its original name.” – Caroline Mitchell Carrico

Greenwich Letterpress

greenwich letterpress stationery

Greenwich Letterpress is a sister-owned company that opened its doors in 2005. With over 14 years in the business, it brings wit and pop-culture wisdom to the community in New York’s West Village.

Greenwich Letterpresses specializes in stationery that you will surely love. They can produce custom-made wedding announcements, greeting cards, notebooks, and other gifts. You may also want to check out their collection of neighborhood key tags. The paper that they use in their products is 100% tree-free post-consumer cotton or is either 100% recycled.


Custom-Made Stationery, Key Tags, Enamel Pins, and more


Address: 15 Christopher St, New York, NY 10014
Phone: (212) 989 7464


“Great store and I love the new location. Really fun place to shop. Always worth the trip. The custom printing is excellent and they are easy to work with. Independent stores like this are disappearing from NYC, sadly.” – C. E.

Paper Source

paper source new york

Paper Source believes that every moment calls for the creation of something special. They thoughtfully design each piece in their store, down to the very last card on their shelves. Paper Source envisions that its customers do something creative every day, whether it giving out thoughtful gifts or by simply celebrating life’s special moments.

Find delight in their hands-on and handcrafted selections. They offer custom rubber stamp cutting to personalized paper lanterns as well. Enjoy their in-store sessions and explore the creative side you have locked inside you. If you want private workshop sessions for parties, they have you covered too.


Journals, Gift Cards, Workshops, and more


Address: 83 Spring St, New York, NY 10012
Phone: (646) 484 5764
Website: store-locator.papersource.com


“Great staff, a wide range of products. I have mobility issues and each staff member checked in to see if I needed any assistance especially when my Access A Ride vehicle came to pick me up. I was smitten by a box of cherry blossom note cards and stock paper for letter writing that I purchased in a light purple with plum-colored envelopes. They made my shopping experience a wonderful thing.” – Eddie Harper

Stationery and Toy World

stationery and toys world nyc

Stationery and Toy World is Manhattan’s Upper West Side toy, game, and hobby shop. Their shelves are stocked with an extensive selection of papers and pens. Look no more for other school supply stores because they also have many choices for your needs. Have a party coming up? No problem. Skim through their party supplies selections and have a blast.

Their prices may seem more expensive than their counterparts on Amazon.com, but you will surely get the worth of your money. Their staff members will be happy to assist you and ensure that you will leave the store with a smile on your face.


Stationery, Toys, Notebooks, Party Supplies, and more


Address: 125 W 72nd St, New York, NY 10023, United States
Phone: +1 212-580-3922


“This is the best place to buy toys. They always have whatever you want or they will get it for you. When I don’t know what to get I tell them the age of my grandchild and they suggest and the kids are happy. The only place to go!” – Laureen Szmulewicz