5 Best Second-hand Stores in Indianapolis 🥇

Best Second-hand Stores in Indianapolis

Below is a list of the top and leading Second-hand Stores in Indianapolis. To help you find the best Second-hand Stores located near you in Indianapolis, we put together our own list based on this rating points list.

Indianapolis’s Best Second-hand Stores: 

The top rated Second-hand Stores in Indianapolis are:

  • Mission 27 Resale – thrift shop providing a variety of items
  • Audrey’s Place – has been providing everyday household thrift items for more than 40 years
  • Consigned by Design – specializes in selling new and gently used fine furniture
  • Goodwill Store – offers a wide variety of items that are sorted by size for easy shopping
  • Style Encore – features gently used women’s casual and business supplies at 90% less than the regular retail

Mission 27 Resale

Mission 27 Resale

 

Mission 27 Resale is a thrift shop providing a variety of items. The shop is managed by the Society of St. Vincent de Paul. The upscale shop features orderly distributed second-hand supplies at the lowest price possible. Furthermore, all purchases go to the funding of the Society’s food pantries and programs. Their Changing Lives Forever program teaches people how to become self-sufficient.

The inventory includes designer pieces and rare finds. Moreover, they accept donations of goods. This includes home decor, housewares, appliances, clothing, and many more. Volunteers may also share this passion with them at the shop.

Products/ Services:

second-hand store

LOCATION: 

Address: 132 Leota St, Indianapolis, IN 46202
Phone: (317) 687-8260
Website:   mission27resale.org

REVIEWS: 

“hecked this place out today for the first time. It’s my new favorite thrift store. Nice selection. Great prices. And very organized! I’ll be back and I’ll bring friends and family! I’ll also be telling people about it!” – Heather Ratcliff

Audrey’s Place  

Audrey's Place  

Audrey’s Place has been providing everyday household thrift items for more than 40 years. They constantly strive to price the lowest prices possible for new and gently-used furniture. Furthermore, they have furniture and home decors for the living rooms, bedrooms, and dining rooms. Their selection includes home storage, tables, mirrors, and pillows. There are also rugs, wall art, and accessory sets.

Some of the brands they carry are Coaster, SierraSleep, and Millennium. Moreover, they display architectural salvages thoroughly checked by the staff. In addition, they have financing and leasing options for every credit and budget range.

Products/ Services:

second-hand store, furniture

LOCATION: 

Address: 1335 Dublin Rd #214a, Columbus, OH 43215
Phone: (614) 205-2208
Website: columbusdefensefirm.com

REVIEWS: 

“B Matt helped me try to find a used fishing rod that fits the reel I bought. Even though we couldn’t find the right kind… he is even going to be keeping an eye out for me, gave me his business card so I can call to check if he has gotten any in stock. I come here often and will continue to do so. Thanks B Matt!” – Brie Joyce

Consigned by Design 

Consigned by Design 

Consigned by Design specializes in selling new and gently used fine furniture. There are two showrooms in Indianapolis. It features sample set-ups and a wide selection of furniture and home decors. Moreover, they have expert sales representatives assisting the clients. They ensure that they take home the best product for them.

The furniture selections cover supplies for the bathroom, bedroom, dining, kitchen, and office. There are also selections of barware, fine china, and textiles. In addition, they display jewelry, bags, and wearables.

Products/ Services:

second-hand store, furniture

LOCATION: 

Address: 7035 E 96th St Suite A, Indianapolis, IN 46250
Phone: (317) 436-7167
Website:  consignedbydesign.com

REVIEWS: 

”Love this place! Beautiful items, excellent quality, great selection! I have never left there, without a few items (that I couldn’t live without 😉). The employees are friendly and very helpful, without being aggressive. This is definitely store you HAVE TO experience (often)!” – Tonia Ehlers

Goodwill Store 

Goodwill Store 

Goodwill Store offers a wide variety of items that are sorted by size for easy shopping. The items are organized by department. There are store assistants that guide the clients to the preferred items. Furthermore, they employ individuals with disabilities, criminal histories, and limited education. They provide them opportunities to support their families and improve themselves.

Moreover, they accept generous donations of household stuff, clothing, and electronics. The shop offers an affordable selection of household items, nooks, furniture, toys, and many more. Their ever-changing inventory guarantees something for everyone.

Products/ Services:

second-hand stores

LOCATION: 

Address: 4420 Lafayette Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46254
Phone: (317) 297-0488
Website:   goodwillindy.org

REVIEWS: 

”I love this Goodwill store it’s the part when you find the item meant for you.” – Marie Butts

Style Encore

Style Encore

Style Encore features gently used women’s casual and business supplies at 90% less than the regular retail. They have a selection that can be used in summer, fall, winter, and spring. Furthermore, they carry top brands and the trendiest styles. Some of the brands they carry are Gap, Old Navy, Nine West, Tiffany & Co., and Fossil. Their inventory includes clothing from top to bottom. There is also outerwear including coats, jackets, and vests.

They display accessories like belts, hats, scarves, gloves, and sunglasses. Moreover, there are selections of handbags, shoes, and jewelry. The shop staff assesses the items to be bought. They offer discounts on selected items or pay for the items with cash.

Products/ Services:

second-hand store

LOCATION: 

Address: 7657 Shelby St, Indianapolis, IN 46227
Phone:  (317) 889-1700
Website: style-encore.com/locations/indianapolis-in-greenwood

REVIEWS: 

”This place is really I found these lovely bracelets and a ring holder but use it for my bracelets. They have nice 2nd hand items. The customer service was good when I was there.” – Jerri Spear