5 Best Sandwich Shops in Chicago, IL

Best Sandwich Shops in Chicago

Below is a list of the top and leading Sandwich Shops in Chicago. To help you find the best Sandwich Shops located near you in Chicago, we put together our own list based on this rating points list.

Chicago’s Best Sandwich Shops:

The top rated Sandwich Shops in Chicago, IL are:

  • Nicole’s Sandwich Shop – is providing an all-around experience
  • J.T.’s Genuine Sandwich Shop – can’t wait to see you in their family-friendly shop
  • Capt’n Nemo’s Rogers Park – is original sub sandwich shop since 1971
  • The Corned Beef Factory Sandwich Shop – has been crafting its signature recipe
  • Potbelly Sandwich Shop – considers you can taste the difference when simple

Nicole’s Sandwich ShopSandwich Shops in Chicago

Nicole’s Sandwich Shop embraces you to a place where great-tasting traditional sandwiches share a menu with freshly made delicious deli sandwiches. Their focus is to captivate their customers by providing an all-around experience through their high-quality products and great attention to customer satisfaction. Nicole’s Sandwich Shop hopes you find everything you need and will do everything they can to meet your expectations.

They are sure your first will not be your last time. They would like to introduce its new addition, Nicole’s Catering. Where they provide nutritional meals to child daycare providers. Nicole’s Sandwich Shop meals are just as impressionable as the delicious subs they serve. Offering quality products and uniqueness in meal preparation.

Products/Services:

Catering & Party Favorites, Products, Services & Menu, Child Care Catering

LOCATION:

Address: 8519 S Ada St, Chicago, IL 60620
Phone: 
(312) 391-1932
Website:
www.nicolessandwichshop.net

REVIEWS:

“The Italian turkey is my favorite just love this place.” – Steven B.

J.T.’s Genuine Sandwich ShopTop Sandwich Shops in Chicago

J.T.’s Genuine Sandwich Shop can’t wait to see you in their cozy, family-friendly shop. Opening JT’s in their very own neighborhood is a dream come true. They are excited to share their family’s favorite scratch-made snacks, soups, sandwiches, salads, and treats for both carnivores and vegetarians alike. Join them for great food and a warm atmosphere in a family-friendly setting.

Products/Services:

Menu, Online Order, Gift Cards, Takeaway, Delivery

LOCATION:

Address: 3970 N Elston Ave, Chicago, IL 60618
Phone: 
(773) 754-7729
Website:
www.jtsgenuine.com

REVIEWS:

“Stopped by for lunch. Breaded pork sandwich. Cup of chili. It was really good. Definitely will return to try more.” – Brandon H.

Capt’n Nemo’s Rogers ParkSandwich Shops Chicago

Capt’n Nemo’s Rogers Park is Chicago’s original sub sandwich shop since 1971, Durability is its own reward. To succeed in Chicago means they are good. Take out food that’s good to take out. Yummy soups, hearty chili, and big sandwiches are what they do. Simple, cost-effective catering unique to Chicago. Enormous enough for huge events but always a personal touch.

Products/Services:

Menu, Catering, Subs, Soups, Chili

LOCATION:

Address: 7367 N Clark St, Chicago, IL 60626
Phone: 
(773) 973-0570
Website:
www.capnemoschicago.com

REVIEWS:

“Their sandwiches are so deliciously different from any other sub sandwich that you can’t really compare. I know it’s a cliche but these sandwiches are a meal! Be hungry.” – Jim T.

The Corned Beef Factory Sandwich ShopGood Sandwich Shops in Chicago

The Corned Beef Factory Sandwich Shop has been crafting its signature recipe of Corned beef in the West Loop of Chicago since 1948. In 2012, as demand grew, they decided to bring their premium corned beef to the local neighbors and the Corned Beef Factory retail sandwich shop was officially open for business. Each day their premium small-batch corned beef and pastrami, as well as their homemade potato chips, are thoroughly made for their loyal customers to enjoy.

Products/Services:

Menu, Catering, Wholesale

LOCATION:

Address: 1016 W Lake St, Chicago, IL 60607
Phone: 
(312) 666-2536
Website:
www.cornedbeeffactory.com

REVIEWS:

“Outstanding!! We had the Rueben, Pastrami, Turkey Ruben, and grilled cheese. All were outstanding! The first two were the best I’ve ever had. Indoor seating in June 2021.” – Matt G.

Potbelly Sandwich ShopOne of the best Sandwich Shops in Chicago

Potbelly Sandwich Shop considers you can taste the difference when simple, high-quality ingredients are used. At Potbelly, they will never skimp on size or quality. Peter Hastings and his wife decided to start serving sandwiches to their curious, collecting customers at their antique shop in the Lincoln Park neighborhood of Chicago.

In 2007 the first drive-thru opens and Crain’s Business adds Potbelly to its “50 Fastest Growing Companies” list. Potbelly also adds salads to its menu to bring even more freshness to customers. They continue to wake up each day with one goal, to make people happy through good vibes and delicious, crave-able food.

Products/Services:

Menu, Catering, Franchising, Gift Cards

LOCATION:

Address: 4709 N Lincoln Ave, Chicago, IL 60625
Phone: 
(773) 275-1218
Website:
www.potbelly.com

REVIEWS:

“I enjoy eating Potbelly’s sandwiches, shakes, and soups. On my recent visit, I tried the shop in Lincoln Square and brought a friend along to try them for the first time. Along with the delicious meal, the service and attention to detail were delightful and the experience has converted my friend who previously only purchased from a competitor sandwich brand.
I’ve been a Potbelly fan since the ’80s. Their sandwiches are still the tops!” – Orlando M.