5 Best Jewellery in Columbus🥇

5 Best Jewellery in Columbus

Below is a list of the top and leading Jewellery in Columbus. To help you find the best Jewellery located near you in Columbus, we put together our own list based on this rating points list.

Columbus’ Best Jewellery:

The top rated Jewellery in Columbus are:

  • Jeff Johnson & Co – are designers, creators, and restorers of fine jewelry
  • Diamond Cellar – ensures you get a personalized experience each time you walk through its doors
  • Jack Seibert Goldsmith & Jeweler – designers can assist you to create whatever your heart wishes
  • Argo & Lehne Jewelers – is passionate about jewelry, art, and individual expression
  • Alexanders Jewelers – has been one of the most trusted names in luxury jewelry in Central Ohio and beyond

Jeff Johnson & CoJeff Johnson & Co

Jeff Johnson & Co are designers, creators, and restorers of fine jewelry. They believe something as personal as jewelry deserves a personal touch. That’s why at Jeff Johnson & Co. you’ll always work directly with one of their talented jewelry artisans. When they are not creating custom jewelry they are skillfully repurposing family heirlooms, tackling difficult repairs, and creating the award-winning designs that fill their showcases. Their artisans have a talent for listening and interpreting.

They’ll work beside you to help develop your vision, bringing it to life with a design that’s ideal for you. Their expectation is that their jewelry is not defined by its price tag or by the way it sparkles from its spot in their display case. They hope what makes an impact is the process of craftsmanship that each piece must move through in order to inspire, delight, and captivate its future owner.


Pendant, Earrings, Necklace, Ring, Engagement Ring


Address: 5025 Arlington Centre Blvd #130, Columbus, OH 43220
Phone: (614) 459-8890
Website: www.jjandcompany.com


“I was a new customer referred to them for a Ring to be resized. Very friendly over the phone and in-person even though I’ve never been a customer. While I was there waiting, I noticed that almost all the customers who came in the store the staff knew them by name which is a good sign that they have repeat loyal customers. They were nice enough to resize my ring in about an hour while I went out to lunch. I know that’s not normal for a jewelry shop, but a goldsmith was available. They even cleaned my wife’s wedding band and engagement ring. I will definitely be back based on their customer service and fair pricing. Thank you to Carol who helped me.” – Doug F.

Diamond CellarDiamond Cellar

Diamond Cellar created in 1947, Diamond Cellar Holdings is now one of the largest self-sufficient jewelry companies in the United States with six stores located in Columbus, Ohio including Nashville, Tennessee, and one in Tulsa, Oklahoma. Together they represent some of the best brands in the world. Their passion has been serving you, their customers, by ensuring you get a personalized experience each time you walk through their doors.

Whether it’s in custom design, sales, or repair, you’ll deal with some of the most skilled and highly trained people in the country. They lead you step by step through the procedure of buying a piece of jewelry to ensure you get exactly what you want. Their roots are in the goldsmith trade, and it’s an area of the business they have steadily grown. They manufacture much of their own jewelry right here in their store, using the best materials and craftsmanship. From setting an engagement diamond to a full-blown custom design, your jewelry never has to leave its store.


Rolex, Patex Philippe, David Yurman, Engagement Rings, Wedding Bands, Diamonds, Jewelry, Watches


Address: 3960 New Bond St, Columbus, OH 43219
Phone: (614) 923-6633
Website: www.diamondcellar.com


“Stephanie and Josh recently helped with the great debate over which watch to get our son for his upcoming college graduation gift. My wife and I very much appreciated their thoughtfulness and insight. Super service. Great people. The best quality. That’s why The Diamond Cellar has been our go-to jewelry store for over 25 years.” – Tom M.

Jack Seibert Goldsmith & JewelerJack Seibert Goldsmith & Jeweler

Jack Seibert Goldsmith & Jeweler has been helping the Upper Arlington and Columbus metropolitan area for over 40 years, centrally located just up the street from Ohio State University-Main Campus. They pride themselves on individually selecting unique pieces of stunning jewelry for their collection, from modern styles to a more vintage feel, they have something for everyone.

Their custom designers can assist you to create whatever your heart wishes whether they specially select the perfect diamond or gemstone to be the focal point for your ring, bracelet, or pendant, or make a special piece using your own jewels. Let their store be your comprehensive services for all your jewelry needs, they have a Goldsmith on-the-spot to complete repairs, as well as an AGS Certified Gemologist Appraiser to ensure your pieces are appraised correctly to the greatest standards.


Custom Designs, Products, Services


Address: 1741 W Lane Ave #1170, Columbus, OH 43221
Phone: (614) 486-4653
Website: www.jackseibert.com


“The engagement ring they created for me is beautiful. I am incredibly pleased with the result. Would highly recommend!” – Connor W.

Argo & Lehne JewelersArgo & Lehne Jewelers

Argo & Lehne Jewelers is located in front of the Kingsdale Shopping Center in the center of Upper Arlington. Whether you’re seeking jewelry restoration, antique jewelry, custom jewelry, appraisals, or anything in between, their proficient staff is ready and eager to accommodate. They are passionate about jewelry, art, and individual expression. They have been around for near a century because they are forward-thinking artisans who embrace your style, whatever style that may be.

This is what makes them the most reliable resource for special, one-of-a-kind jewelry that gets you. A third-generation jeweler, their legacy revolves around the connection with their customers and superior workmanship. It’s made them the number one trusted jeweler in Columbus. Their customers are among the most unique, vibrant, individualistic people in their community.


Engagement, Jewelry, Collections, Services


Address: 3100 Tremont Rd, Columbus, OH 43221
Phone: (614) 457-6261
Website: www.argolehne.com


“The best Jewelers ever. I bought the wedding band and engagement ring here for they have an incredible choice of diamonds and settings all of the highest quality! She is the best around, extremely knowledgeable, so helpful, and made us feel extremely comfortable. go back often to have her ring cleaned.” – Annette V.

Alexanders JewelersAlexanders Jewelers

Alexanders Jewelers has been one of the most trusted names in luxury jewelry in Central Ohio and beyond. They have been committed to offering top-quality fashion jewelry, engagement rings, wedding bands, luxury watches, and accessories since 2000. Their full-service jewelry store provides customers in Central Ohio with singular items of outstanding quality.

Two decades ago, Alex Khvalsky began his profession in watches and fine jewelry as the Timepiece Coordinator for a jewelry boutique at Easton Town Center. As his expertise in luxury timepieces grew, Alex decided it was time to strike out on his own. Its doors of Alexander’s Jewelers opened in 2000 in the Short North Arts District of Columbus.


Designers, Jewelry, Watches, Accessories


Address: 689 N High St, Columbus, OH 43215
Phone: (614) 233-6666
Website: www.alexanderscolumbus.com


“We could not recommend Alexanders more!! We received nothing but amazing service from Shane who helped us design the perfect ring. He communicated with us throughout the entire process and help guide us with flawless customization. Beyond thrilled with the results! ” – Teresa M.