Below is a list of the top and leading Italian Restaurants in Indianapolis. To help you find the best Italian Restaurants located near you in Indianapolis, we put together our own list based on this rating points list.
Indianapolis’s Best Italian Restaurants:
The top rated Italian Restaurants in Indianapolis are:
- Mama Carolla’s – serves authentic Italian dishes in a Mediterranean-style restaurant with hints of Spanish and Italian flairs.
- Iozzo’s Garden of Italy – offers an array of delicious Italian cuisine for dine-in and catering
- Sangiovese Ristorante – has constantly served authentic and best-tasting Italian dishes since 1994
- Amore! – brings the taste of Italy to the community in a locally owned and operated Italian restaurant
- Catello’s – offers an exquisite Italian dining experience with good food and drink selections.
Mama Carolla’s serves authentic Italian dishes in a Mediterranean-style restaurant with hints of Spanish and Italian flairs. The restaurant boasts California Stucco designs and period fixtures. There is a wood-burning in the fireplace during winter nights. Furthermore, they have an array of antipasti. This includes Caprese salad, fried ravioli, and steamed mussels. They also serve pasta with white sauce, herbed oil, or red sauce e options.
The restaurant’s specialties are manicotti, traditional beef lasagna, and chicken rigatoni. Moreover, they serve entrees for chicken, pork, steak, and veal. The dessert selections include tiramisu, cannoli, and creme brulee. There is also an extensive list of local and international wines.
Address: 1031 E 54th St, Indianapolis, IN 46220
Phone: (317) 259-9412
”This is a really cute restaurant. I had the strip steak and it us the best I ever had. Exceptional flavor & cooked to a perfect medium. The mashed potatoes are excellent. My husband had the pork chop and spaghetti and he loved it. We usually get the toasted ravioli and dipping sauce for an appetizer and it is sooo good. Their desserts are fantastic too.” – Lori Compton
Iozzo’s Garden of Italy
Iozzo’s Garden of Italy offers an array of delicious Italian cuisine for dine-in and catering. They offer dishes made from recipes passed from generation to generation. Furthermore, their catering has numerous options for small to large events. Their dishes include calamari fritti, asparagus soup, and selections of pizza. There are also pasta selections like bolognese and fettuccini alfredo.
The restaurant’s signature collection cover heritage liquors, wines, and cocktails. Moreover, the signature collection includes barrel-aged cocktails, whiskey, and limoncello. They also provide an extensive list of local and international wines.
Address: 946 S Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN 46225
Phone: (317) 974-1100
”My girlfriend and I went here in a date. It was a nice day and we sat in the patio. It has a great astetic. Nice selection of wine. We got a bottle of Mary’s blend that we enjoyed. The food was excellent. I recommend the lasagna. It was a little pricey so be prepared for that. Overall good experience.” – Nate Diller
Sangiovese Ristorante has constantly served authentic and best-tasting Italian dishes since 1994. The dishes are prepared with the finest ingredients. Furthermore, the restaurant’s laid-back atmosphere makes diners enjoy their meals and wine. There are two locations in Indiana. Private dining may be availed with prior reservation.
The restaurant serves Italain favrouets like pasta and antipasti. For example, they serve mussels, penne, linguini, and spaghetti. There are also selections of salads like caesar salad and caprese salad. Moreover, their specialties include osso buco, samomone al piatto, and rosticcian
Address: 2727 E 86th St #110, Indianapolis, IN 46240
Phone: (317) 757-5913
”Absolutely delicious. Loved the massive attack music in the background as well… Very nice atmosphere. My first time here and I’ll definitely be back.” – Brian Usinger
Amore! brings the taste of Italy to the community in a locally owned and operated Italian restaurant. There are selections of mouthwatering Italian dishes prepared daily. They see the premium ingredients. Moreover, they have selections of steak, pasta, and antipasti. examples for antipasti include arancini and bruschetta. They also serve their chicken and veal dishes with salad, pasta, and bread.
The pasta selections include fettuccine alfredo and cheese ravioli. Furthermore, there are chef’s specialties. The dishes are all served with salad, vegetables, and bread service. For example, they serve pesto salmon, traditional lasagna, and shrimp fra Diavolo.
Address: 9757 Fall Creek Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46256
Phone: (317) 643-9494
”Just good food. We finished the appetizers in speed record and the food was just divine! The vibe is also so chill and relaxing! Their bread is the softest as well even the day after!” – Mary Anne
Catello’s offers an exquisite Italian dining experience with good food and drink selections. It is a chef-owned restaurant with dishes made from the first ingredients. The dishes are also made from scratch and prepared daily. Furthermore, the food is available for carryout, dine-in, and delivery. The menu consists of sliced aged cheeses and meats, Napoli salad, and Caprese salad. They also serve a combination of panini and salad.
There are also pasta selections of spaghetti, lasagna, and ravioli. Moreover, the chef’s specialty dishes are Agnello and caprino, Spingola and Ceci, and Iberico and funghi. There are selections f desserts like pannacotta and fruit tart.
Address: 4901 E 82nd St, Indianapolis, IN 46250
Phone: (317) 516-5766
”Love the atmosphere here, wait staff if very friendly the charcuterie boards are the beat in town. Fresh made mozzarella and great aged cheese and meats. Nice wine selection, you can find and affordable wine from the list. Great Italian desert and coffee selections. Our go to Italian restaurant in Indy.” – KW
Jeanie Burford is a reporter for Kev’s Best. After graduating from UCLA, Amy got an internship at a local radio station and worked as a beat reporter and producer. Jeanie has also worked as a columnist for The Brookings Register. Amy covers economy and community events for Kev’s Best.