Below is a list of the top and leading Italian Restaurants in Columbus. To help you find the best Italian Restaurants located near you in Columbus, we put together our own list based on this rating points list.
Columbus’s Best Italian Restaurants:
The top rated Italian Restaurants in Columbus are:
- Martini Modern Italian- serves authentic traditional Italian cuisine with a modernized facility
- Pasqualone’s – serves pasta with classic entrees
- Basi Italia – brings the romantic vibes of Italy in its intimate nook
- Claudiana Italian Restaurant- offers a homey Italian cuisine with a full bar
- Guiseppe’s Ritrovo – provides a cozy atmosphere for you to enjoy your Italian classics
Martini Modern Italian
Martini Modern Italian serves authentic traditional Italian cuisine with a modernized facility. The contemporary space is adorned with chandeliers to set the mood. It provides creative interpretation of Italian cuisine from their world-class chefs. Their menu is very unique and interesting to new comers and regulars alike. It fused traditional Italian practices with modern twists to create an innovative dining experience. They take pride on their made from scratch pasta. Aside from that, their dishes only use the freshest ingredients and serve hand-pulled mozzarella.
Italian cuisine, dine-in, delivery
Address: 445 N High St, Columbus, OH 43215, United States
“Definitely coming back. Service was great. Had a great seat. Food was amazing! Not just run of the mill italian, very authentic delicious entree’s and cocktails.” – Alyssa Sharp
Pasqualone’s is a family business of Italian restaurant. It serves pasta with classic entrees. Their impeccable wine caps off the complete dining experience. They want their diners to feel comfortable and at home with their homey vibe. Their staff are very friendly and approachable. The chef prepares dishes based on recipes that are passed from generation to generation. Their services also include private dinner parties. If you’re looking for a relaxing space to enjoy your Italian food fix, Pasqualone’s is your best find.
Italian cuisine, dine-in, delivery
Address: 5766 Emporium Square, Columbus, OH 43231, United States
“Pasqualone’s was the perfect choice. From the minute you walk into this warm and welcoming restaurant, you know that everyone cares about the details. Chef David and his superb, melt in your mouth pastas, Matthew the fabulous mix-master and general master of kindness ensuring all is well.” – Al Mckinney
Basi Italia brings the romantic vibes of Italy in its intimate nook. Located in a Victorian Village neighborhood, it creates the atmosphere of togetherness. Northern Italian dishes are served in right portions to satisfy your Italian cuisine cravings. They serve the best appetizers and desserts that are truly Italian. Bring innovative twists in the current dishes makes their diners come back often. It may be a casual restaurant but their food proves to be superbly tasty and full of flavor.
Italian Cuisine, delivery, dine-in, on-site pick-up
Address: 811 Highland St, Columbus, OH 43215, United States
“Excellent food! Most definitely one of my favorite restaurants! Love the cozy laid back atmosphere!” – Tracie Hughes
Claudiana Italian Restaurant
Claudiana Italian Restaurant‘s intimate vibe offers a homey Italian cuisine with a full bar. They have been known in creating their pasta from scratch and using high quality fresh ingredients. Their menu covers a lot of authentic Italian dishes for the young and old alike. To top off the atmosphere made by their white tablecloth covered tables and candles, wine and martinis are also sold. It creates a cozy atmosphere for family diners. Their menu include pasta and pizza, different salads, and soups. They also have a children’s menu which are tasty and fit for a child’s taste buds.
pizza, Italian cuisine, delivery, takeaway, dine-in
Address: 8475 Sancus Blvd, Columbus, OH 43240, United States
“This Italian restaurant is delicious! Very classy and respectable employees who are delightfully educated on any questions you have. The food was absolutely amazing! Had a great dinner! Would 10/10 recommend to anyone and everyone!” – Rachel Drockton
Guiseppe’s Ritrovo provides a cozy atmosphere for you to enjoy your Italian classics. The martini menu and various wines. Guiseppe and Vesna established the restaurant in 1996 and has been serving delicious dishes for years. It is located on the Main Street and warmly welcomes old and new customers. They treat their diners as part of their family. The warmth of their restaurant flows through the authentic Italian dishes. The dishes are served with aesthetic designs. The flavors of their food are very tasty and greatly captures its Italian roots.
Italian cuisine, dine-in, takeaway, delivery
Address: 2268 E Main St, Columbus, OH 43209, United States
“A top spot for delicious Italian food. Came here on a Friday I think. The staff was friendly and sociable. This place has a great feel to it.” – Elijah Fletcher