5 Best Greek Food in Indianapolis🥇

5 Best Greek Food in Indianapolis

Below is a list of the top and leading Greek Food in Indianapolis. To help you find the best Greek Food located near you in Indianapolis, we put together our own list based on this rating points list.

Indianapolis’ Best Greek Food:

The top-rated Greek Food in Indianapolis are:

  • The Greek Islands – casual outpost offering a family vibe for classic Greek dishes including its famous flaming cheese.
  • The Parthenon Restaurant – strip-mall eatery serving classic Greek fare & vegan options in a relaxed, offbeat atmosphere.
  • ATHENS ON 86th – classic Greek decor, traditional cuisine & occasional belly dancing in a strip-mall locale.
  • Peto’s Authentic Greek Restaurant – the only time to eat diet food is while you’re waiting for PETOS’ Souvlaki.
  • Gyro Stop – counter-serve place in a strip mall offering Mediterranean comfort classics like falafel & shawarma.

The Greek Islands

5 Best Greek Food in Indianapolis

The Greek Islands is one of the best and oldest independently-owned Greek restaurants in the Indianapolis area. The restaurant has been in business for almost three decades serving authentic, made-to-order Greek cuisine straight from Papa Louie and Mama Fofo’s recipes. If you want home-cooked authentic Greek cuisine coupled with an amazing, warm, and friendly atmosphere, Greek Islands Restaurant is the destination for you. Their dishes are made from only the best and freshest ingredients available on the market. They also have gluten-free dishes and a limited vegan selection. This one-stop Greek eats shop also offers catering to those events and parties that need a little bit of fresh Greek touch.

Lunch menu, dinner menu, gluten-free menu, catering.

Address: 906 S. Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN 46225
Phone: (317) 636-0700
Website: greekislandsrestaurant.com

Fantastic food. Everything I ate was delicious. The Greek beer was passable. The servers were friendly and spoke Greek. They even taught me a couple of phrases. Highly recommended. – Michael Patterson

The Parthenon Restaurant

The Best Greek Food in Indianapolis

The Parthenon Restaurant is a popular local mom and pop Middle-Eastern and Mediterranean resto that serves authentic, homemade traditional cuisine. They specialize in rotisserie gyros, chicken and lamb kebab, and shawarma among the large collection of delectable Greek eats. Their dishes are handmade, created from only the freshest and finest ingredients available in Indianapolis. The Parthenon offers daily specials for their lunch and dinner menus. They also have some of the friendliest staff that will assist you from the moment you walk into the moment you leave with your bellies stuffed with Greek tasty goodness.

Dine-in, reservations, events, order online.

Address: 1482 W 86th St, Indianapolis, IN 46260
Phone: (317) 228-1111
Website: parthenonindy.com

This restaurant was great! The food was delicious and came out hot and quick. The dessert menu is top-notch! The staff was very friendly and attentive. Highly recommend! – Jennifer Slagle

ATHENS on 86th

Best Greek Food in Indianapolis

ATHENS on 86th is a family-owned authentic Greek restaurant prepared with loved and served with joy by Tina Konduris and her family. This Greek eatery is a fan-favorite in Indianapolis for their gyros, lamb dishes, and fresh seafood. There is something for everyone’s taste in this modest hidden gem located on the Northwest side of Indy. Athens on 86th is open for lunch and dinner from Tuesday to Sunday. The caring staff will help you out if this is your first Greek restaurant outing and will make sure your experience will be a thing to remember!

Dine-in, curbside pickup, lunch, dinner, entertainment, catering.

Address: 2284 W 86th St West, Indianapolis, IN 46260
Phone: (317) 879-8644
Website: athenson86th.com

My favorite spot for tasty Greek food. Super place to meet and chat with co-workers. The service was sociable and attentive. – R. Reeves

Peto’s Authentic Greek Restaurant

Indianapolis Best Greek Food

Peto’s Authentic Greek Restaurant is a special restaurant with very special food. From Greece to Indianapolis, Peto’s offers a money-back guarantee if you are not satisfied with the dish that you ordered or if the food you ordered tastes similar to other Greek restos. They pride themselves on the unique flavor of their foods, being tasty on an entire level of its own. Their collection of utterly delectable dishes and cuisine coupled with their top-notch customer experience makes Peto’s one of the best go-to destinations if you are looking for Greek food in Indy.

Dine-in, curbside pickup, delivery, order online, catering, e-commerce.

Address: 6020 E 82nd St H&M suit #1411 Main Entrance, Indianapolis, IN 46250
Phone: (317) 842-2724
Website: petosfamily.com

Excellent and authentic! Please come and eat here as this is a family-owned business and they really need our support in driving up their customer base during the COVID outbreak. You will love it! And the prices are so reasonable! – Daniel Pfeiffer

Gyro Stop

Indianapolis's Best Greek Food

Gyro Stop proudly serves authentic Mediterranean cuisine in Indianapolis and its surrounding areas. Founded in 2005 by Luke Amro, the first iteration of Gyro Stop was opened with $100 and a dream in Mr. Amro’s heart that the secret sauce recipe he has will blow up. Luke’s non-stop hard work as he strives to serve Indianapolis with arguably the best gyros in town is what sets the store apart from other Greek restaurants and eateries in the city. Gyro Stop’s never-ending quest for quality service and eats is reflected in the ingredients they use that are the freshest and the best quality available locally.

Authentic Greek food, order online.

Address: 5438 W 86th St, Indianapolis, IN 46268
Phone: (317) 471-8607
Website: gyrostopindy.com

A very good place, food is delicious and hopes to come again. The chief is very kind and the service is amazing, wish him all the best. – Sadiq Hameed