5 Best Gift Shops in Indianapolis🥇

5 Best Gift Shops in Indianapolis
Birthday gifts. Source: Pexels

Below is a list of the top and leading Gift Shops in Indianapolis. To help you find the best Gift Shops located near you in Indianapolis, we put together our own list based on this rating points list.

Indianapolis’ Best Gift Shops:

The top rated Gift Shops in Indianapolis are:

  • Global Gifts – Nora Plaza – is committed to providing fair income and employment
  • Twisted Sisters – is an extraordinary shopping experience
  • Black Sheep Gifts – has been in the business since 2010
  • Silver In the City – has super friendly and helpful sales staff
  • Artifacts Gallery – plays an essential role in the local Indianapolis community

Global Gifts – Nora Plaza

Global Gifts - Nora Plaza
Global Gifts – Nora Plaza. Source: Screenshot from www.globalgiftsft.com

Global Gifts – Nora Plaza is committed to providing fair income and employment to disadvantaged artisans and producers and helping their customers spend their shopping dollars in ways that empower people and communities around the globe. They are a non-profit business committed to creating sustainable economic opportunities and safe and equitable working conditions for disadvantaged artisans and farmers around the world.

From jewelry and home goods to toys and food items, its stores are filled with handmade, one-of-a-kind items from over 40 different countries.

Products/Services:

Books & Learnings, Mystery Boxes, Jewelry, Accessories, Clothing, Home Decor, Kids, Food & Beverage, Kitchen & Dining, Spiritual, Bath & Body, Office & Stationery, Cards & Giftwrap

LOCATION:

Address: 1300 E 86th St #17, Indianapolis, IN 46240
Phone: (317) 569-0670
Website: www.globalgiftsft.com

REVIEWS:

“I really love this shop! Mostly run by volunteer making a difference selling fair trade items. Great jewelry, unique gift cards, scarfs, bags, kitchen gadgets, candles, all sorts of gift items. I love coming here and checking out items from around the world. Fun and polite volunteers and awesome gift items. Check it out!” – Stacey C.

Twisted Sisters

Source: Pexels
Source: Pexels

Twisted Sisters is an extraordinary shopping experience. Always something new, never stale. A truly distinctive boutique nestled on Indy’s Northeast side. Visit them and see what treasures you may discover. Twisted Sisters is your go-to gift shop that features handpicked specialty gifts and decor items. Let them help you with all of your gifting needs. They have nothing you need but everything you want.

Products/Services:

Jewelry, Soaps, Handbags, Glass Works, Food Items, Kitchen Tools, Decorative Items, Perfume

LOCATION:

Address: 3937 E 82nd St, Indianapolis, IN 46240
Phone: (317) 841-7177
Website: www.twistedindy.com

REVIEWS:

“Awesome place for gifts and home decor. Their funny coasters are the best too.” – Brian S.

Black Sheep Gifts

Black Sheep Gifts
Black Sheep Gifts. Source: Screenshot from www.blacksheepgiftshop.com

Black Sheep Gifts opened in May 2010. After moving to the Irvington neighborhood in 2000, owner Lisa Bennett said it was hard to find a good greeting card. Following the death of her father, Frank, she decided to invest his life insurance money and become an entrepreneur. The business name is registered with the state as Thanks, Frank LLC as a tribute to her father. She was known as the black sheep of her family, but on her father’s side, there are only black sheep with a few greys in the herd. Hence the name Black Sheep Gifts.

Products/Services:

Lotions & Potions, Baby, Games, Toys, Kitchen, Fun & Funny, Products That Give Back, Clothing

LOCATION:

Address: 5626 E Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46219
Phone: (317) 602-5442
Website: www.blacksheepgiftshop.com

REVIEWS:

“I fell in love with this shop! I cannot wait to go back. Such cute, unique gifts!” – Traci R.

Silver In the City

Silver In the City
Silver In the City. Source: Screenshot from www.silverinthecity.com

Silver In the City is a Bricks and Mortar shop where they believe that providing a welcoming, fun, informative shopping experience is of the utmost importance. You will find so much more than they have online, and super friendly and helpful sales staff to share product knowledge, offer gift suggestions, and reach items on the top shelves for you. Back in 2000, while everybody else was barreling down to their fortified basements, ready to defend their stockpiles of distilled water and fruit jerky, they optimistically decided to establish an unconventional little gift shop that sold jewelry, housewares, and anything else that tickled their fancy.

Products/Services:

Gifts For Dads, Gifts For Grads, Health & Wellness, Jewelry, Housewares, Gift Cards

LOCATION:

Address: 434 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Phone: (317) 955-9925
Website: www.silverinthecity.com

REVIEWS:

“Gave my mom the puzzle subscription for mother’s day this year! She (and my dad) have loved having new puzzles arrive each week. The puzzles are of excellent quality and fun variety! There was a delay in the final puzzle shipping and Erick (from Carmel location) was so helpful on the phone and went above and beyond to get it worked out! Absolutely LOVE this store!” – Andrea G.

Artifacts Gallery

Artifacts Gallery
Artifacts Gallery. Source: Screenshot from www.artifactsindy.com

Artifacts Gallery plays an essential role in the local Indianapolis community by connecting art lovers with art makers. Artifacts were co-founded by Ann Kaplan and her dear friend Dotty, both originally East-Coasters who had landed in the Midwest. Their passion was arts, crafts, and connecting people with beautiful handcrafted objects. The handmade movement was in full effect, and so Artifacts Gallery was born in Ann’s living room.

She became involved in craft councils, juried art fairs, created an investment group, befriended artists, and lobbied the local government to protect small businesses.

Products/Services:

Jewelry, Ceramics, Glass, Wood, Made in Indiana, Gift Cards

LOCATION:

Address: 6327 Guilford Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46220
Phone: (317) 255-1178
Website: www.artifactsindy.com

REVIEWS:

“Really cool store! They have a lot of unique items. We enjoyed just browsing around.” – Cody P.