5 Best Fish and Chips in Indianapolis 🥇

5 Best Fish and Chips in Indianapolis

Below is a list of the top and leading Fish and Chips in Indianapolis. To help you find the best Fish and Chips located near you in Indianapolis, we put together our own list based on this rating points list.

Indianapolis’s Best Fish and Chips:

The top-rated Fish and Chips in Indianapolis are:

  • Chatham Tap – British-style pub popular with soccer fans offers local & import beers on tap & serves global fare.
  • Manley’s Irish Mutt – casual neighborhood pub offering Irish & American fare along with draft beer & sports on TV.
  • Aristocrat Pub & Restaurant – casual pub eats served in a restored 1933 pub with 60 beers on tap & walls decked in vintage finds.
  • Loughmiller’s Pub & Eatery – upbeat tavern doling out burgers, sandwiches & other American pub grub in relaxed environs.
  • O’Reilly’s Irish Pub and Restaurant – convivial Irish pub serving American bar fare, draft beers & whiskeys amid sports-tuned TVs.

Chatham Tap

5 Best Fish and Chips in Indianapolis

Chatham Tap is an English pub that has three branches across Indianapolis. The three branches are in Mass Ave., the second is in Butler University, and the last is in Fishers. Chatham Tap maintains its laid-back and neighborhood-friendly atmosphere while innovating when it comes to its menu. This English pub specializes in sandwiches and appetizers alongside their very popular fish and chips, alongside other pub favorites that go perfectly with beer. Their staff are also very friendly and chill, and will serve you like you are family. Chatham is also the perfect place to watch football games albeit, earlier in the morning so you might want to set that alarm.

Products/Services:
Fish ‘n chips, drinks, starters, salads, sarnies, house specialties, burgers, pizza, desserts, sides, to-go

LOCATION:
Address: 719 Massachusetts Ave. Indianapolis, IN 46204
Phone: (317) 917-8425
Website: chathamtap.com

REVIEWS:
Got the angel wings and they were fabulous! Kinda sweet, kind of spicy, and very tasty. Also got the portobello fries and they were different but really good. Will definitely be back for some more wings!! – Mindy Rainwater

Manley’s Irish Mutt

The Best Fish and Chips in Indianapolis

Manley’s Irish Mutt is a popular and homey Irish pub located in the heart of Indy. This Irish pub has grown to become one of the go-to spots for food like fish and chips and another pub fare since opening in 2011. Manley’s Irish Mutt is owned and operated by husband-and-wife Mike and Jennifer Manley who are Indianapolis natives who wanted to provide the community of Indianapolis a spot where family and friends alike can hang out and share good food, good drinks, in a good atmosphere. The Mutt is known for its collection of authentic Irish and American fare like its widely popular fish and chips, burgers, sandwiches, and beer list. Want to hang out and chill with friends? Manly’s Irish Mutt is the perfect place to wine and dine.

Products/Services:
Fish & chips, chicken tenders, Shepard’s pie, drinks, tacos, desserts

LOCATION:
Address: 7041 E 10th St. Indianapolis, IN 46219
Phone: (317) 351-0009
Website: manleysirishmutt.com

REVIEWS:
Very nice neighborhood Pub and Eatery and great food and great service! Everybody has a little Irish mutt in them! I highly recommend a pint of Smithwick’s and the Philly sandwich. – James Hardison

Aristocrat Pub & Restaurant

Indianapolis Best Fish and Chips

Aristocrat Pub & Restaurant is a premier pub and restaurant that is located near Hamilton and Marion counties. This pub showcases over 60 delectable craft beers alongside their scrumptious menu of pub fare. Aristocrat Pub & Restaurant also highlights private upstairs dining for those who want reserved dining where you can also host events such as weddings and birthdays. Their menu consists of mouth-watering treats like fish and chips, pizza, burgers, seafood options, pasta, and more. If you are in Indy and are looking for a premium pub dining experience, Aristocrat Pub & Restaurant should be your top pick.

Products/Services:
Fish & chips, nachos, quesadilla, soups, salads, burgers, sandwiches, drinks

LOCATION:
Address: 5212 N. College Ave. Indianapolis, IN 46220
Phone: (317) 283-7388
Website: aristocratpub.com

REVIEWS:
Split a tenderloin and enjoy the plentiful outdoor seating and decent beer selection! This was our first time, spontaneous find, highly recommended. – Leigh Rusyn

Loughmiller’s Pub & Eatery

Best Fish and Chips in Indianapolis

Loughmiller’s Pub & Eatery is one of the best pubs in Indianapolis who is also considered a standalone establishment. This means Loughmiller’s does not belong to any big franchises, which adds to its charm. Loughmiller’s provides a rustic and warm atmosphere to those looking to wine and dine in an authentic pub. The atmosphere is relaxed and the sights, sounds, and smell is as authentic as you will get. They provide live music from local bands and musicians, an extensive beer list, events, and an excellent menu of pub fares like fish and chips, burgers, sandwiches, and more. If you are looking for authenticity and quality mixed into one pub, then Loughmiller’s Pub & Eatery is the perfect place for you.

Products/Services:
Fish & chips, burgers, American fare, beer list, live music, events, order online

LOCATION:
Address: 301 W. Washington Indianapolis, Indiana 46204
Phone: (317) 638-7380
Website: loughmillerspub.com

REVIEWS:
One of the best little pubs in downtown Indy. Dave Danny and Scott and the rest of their staff run a class act establishment. The food is great but the service is better. – Jameson Terzini

O’Reilly’s Irish Pub and Restaurant

Indianapolis's Best Fish and Chips

O’Reilly’s Irish Pub and Restaurant is a family-owned and operated business located in downtown Indianapolis. This premier Irish pub and restaurant has been serving traditional Irish cuisine for years alongside fan-favorite Guinness on tap 24/7. O’Reilly’s highlights authentic Irish fare like their insanely popular fish and chips, burgers, and sandwiches that goes perfectly well with any drink. Their staff is very friendly and chill, adding to the homey atmosphere that O’Reilly’s have. This Irish pub is very enticing, from their amazing customer service, relaxed and rustic atmosphere, and delectable food options, O’Reilly’s is one of the best bars you can hang out in Indy.

Products/Services:
Pub bites, wraps, and sandwiches, in a bowl, Irish fare, The Irish Greens, burgers, sides

LOCATION:
Address: 36 S. Pennsylvania Street, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Phone: (317) 974-0674
Website: oreillysirishbar.com

REVIEWS:
The place was really quiet on a Friday night! Kayla was a fantastic bartender! Real personable and kept the drinks flowing! Highly recommend and we will be back again! – Dylan Phillips