5 Best Caterers in Indianapolis🥇

5 Best Caterers in Indianapolis
Catering event. Source: Pexels

Below is a list of the top and leading Caterers in Indianapolis. To help you find the best Caterers located near you in Indianapolis, we put together our own list based on this rating points list.

Indianapolis’ Best Caterers:

The top rated Caterers in Indianapolis are:

  • Nameless Catering’s – menu features a dining style to attract any kind of event
  • Mills Catering LLC – offers a variety of service styles and menu options
  • Sahm’s Catering – provides first-class catering for any events
  • Black Plate Catering – provides its guests with gourmet food solutions
  • MCL Catering – provides services to private parties, corporate events, or weddings

Nameless Catering

Nameless Catering
Nameless Catering. Source: Screenshot from www.namelesscatering.com

Nameless Catering is a child of two worlds—the perceptive taste of restaurateur Jeremy Brown along with the business acumen of entrepreneurial spirit. When a chance to rent a little kitchen in Fountain Square appeared, Jeremy found himself confronted with a new door to an unexplored frontier. Nameless Catering started in January 2014 as a delivery-only catering service.

Surprisingly, Nameless Catering had been making quite a name for itself in the Indianapolis area. Brown receives so many requests for additional menu items he brought on an Executive Chef to create new items. Nameless Catering menu features a dining style to attract any kind of event or time of day.

They have been feeding the people of the Hoosier State since 2013, and continue to evolve their menu offerings to truly feature a little something for everyone.

Products/Services:

Corporate Catering, Wedding Catering, Bar Service

LOCATION:

Address: 115 N Park Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46202
Phone: 
(317) 344-8449
Website:
www.namelesscatering.com

REVIEWS:

“Nameless Catering has a great variety of options to choose from. Their Buffalo Mac & Cheese from their BBQ menu is the bomb! I would highly recommend it!” – Hannah V.

Mills Catering LLC

Mills Catering LLC
Mills Catering LLC. Source: Screenshot from www.millscatering.com

Mills Catering LLC started almost two decades ago with a simple mission to make good food for good people. Since their humble beginnings, they’ve kept the same, honest standard with their food and their clients: creative menus, straightforward pricing, and a personalized approach to your event. They’ve been there for your ordinary days: continental breakfasts at the office, working lunches or suppers for that important client.

They’ve also been there for your favorite days: surprise birthdays, baby dedications, bridal showers, anniversaries, retirement celebrations, graduations, and wedding receptions. They also offer a variety of service styles and menu options for whatever your day holds.

Products/Services:

Weddings, Corporate Events, Private Parties, Special Events

LOCATION:

Address: 2828 E 55th Pl, Indianapolis, IN 46220
Phone: 
(317) 254-0705
Website:
www.millscatering.com

REVIEWS:

“I cannot recommend Mills Catering enough. Delicious food and unmatched customer service.” – Bethany C.

Sahm’s Catering

Sahm's Catering
Sahm’s Catering. Source: Screenshot from www.sahmscateringcompany.com

Sahm’s Catering provides first-class catering for weddings, corporate events and social gatherings in and around the Indianapolis area since 1986. Serving more than four million customers and executing more than 40,000 events has allowed them to fine-tune their menu, streamline their service, and ensure satisfaction on each and every job.

Sahm’s Catering offers complete food service with a wide variety of menu options, from box lunches to international buffets and even onsite action stations. They also offer beverage service beginning with the basics such as soda, iced tea, and lemonade moving all the way up to premium bars. Their dedicated chefs are happy to customize any of their menus to fit the specific needs.

You can call to speak with one of their catering coordinators to learn more about their complementary services and monthly specials.

Products/Services:

Weddings, Corporate Events, Social Events

LOCATION:

Address: 1 American Square, Indianapolis, IN 46282
Phone: 
(317) 536-1305
Website:
www.sahmscateringcompany.com

REVIEWS:

“We went with the bbq buffet for our wedding meal. Shelby did a great job communicating with me throughout the planning process. The employees were very professional at the event. Above all the food was great. Green bean casserole was a bit hit. Plenty of options on the catering menu to choose from. They were also good about providing gluten-free meals for my guests who have celiac disease.” – Katie D.

Black Plate Catering

Black Plate Catering
Black Plate Catering. Source: Screenshot from www.blackplatecatering.com

Black Plate Catering is dedicated to provides its guests with gourmet food solutions and superior service. Whether a need full-on event design, catering with onsite staffing, or just cuisine or bar service, they are experts at helping to solidify the reputation as the host or hostess with the most quality, elegance, professionalism, and personality.

They offer service with a smile—but not the fake smiles that have been shamed into most customer service workers. These are genuine smiles, because they love their job, and they love making their guests just as happy as can be. Black Plate Catering, they recognize that each event that crosses their path is as beautiful and unique as a snowflake.

They accommodate individual design, catering, and hosting needs, they offer their clients a variety of customized services.

Products/Services:

Events, Food & Bar, Venues

LOCATION:

Address: 2025 E 46th St, Indianapolis, IN 46205
Phone: 
(317) 255-8030
Website:
www.blackplatecatering.com

REVIEWS:

“They have so many wonderful options to choose from and all of the food was incredibly delicious. The presentation was also wonderful and the caterers were very attentive and friendly. They were wonderful to work with!” – Caleb C.

MCL Catering

MCL Catering
MCL Catering. Source: Screenshot from www.mclcatering.com

MCL Catering prepares delicious homemade meals from the freshest ingredients and provides services to private parties, corporate events, or weddings. So whether you need to fill a boardroom with the smell of deliciousness or you need your party or wedding guests served by the very best on your most important day, no one caters to you as they do.

They want wedding planning to be as fun and stress-free as possible. Their catering specialists would love to design a complimentary bridal tasting for you and your significant other. Get in touch with them to learn more about the bridal tasting experience.

Products/Services:

Weddings, Corporate Events, Private Parties

LOCATION:

Address: 2730 E 62nd St, Indianapolis, IN 46220
Phone: 
(855) 625-3836
Website:
www.mclcatering.com

REVIEWS:

“MCL has catered our fundraising event for several years and the experience is always fantastic! Leading up to the event, Jessica keeps us well informed and has always been highly attentive at the event as well. And, the food is delicious! A wonderful experience all around!” – Sara J.