5 Best Cakes in Milwaukee, WI

Best Cakes in Milwaukee

Below is a list of the top and leading Cakes in Milwaukee. To help you find the best Cakes located near you in Milwaukee, we put together our own list based on this rating points list.

Milwaukee’s Best Cakes:

The top rated Cakes in Milwaukee, WI are:

  • Aggie’s Bakery & Cake Shop – is home to Milwaukee’s best cakes & bakery
  • Classy Girl Cupcakes –  caters to hundreds of weddings and corporate events a year
  • Scordato Bakery Inc – offers custom cakes for every occasion
  • Rich’s House of Cakes – selling custom cakes for a wide range of holidays and events
  • National Bakery & Deli – has been voted the #1 bakery in Milwaukee

Aggie’s Bakery & Cake ShopCakes in Milwaukee

Aggie’s Bakery & Cake Shop Milwaukee’s top cakes and bakery delivery service can be found here. Since 1977, Aggie’s amazing cake and original buttercream recipe have wowed consumers, and their reputation for quality, stunning designs, and delectable tastes is unrivaled. They are a family-owned and operated bakery, and it is their passion to create something unique for your next event.

Products/Services:

Birthday Cakes, Wedding Cakes

LOCATION:

Address: 7328 W Greenfield Ave, West Allis, Milwaukee, WI 53214
Phone: (414) 482-1288
Website: www.aggiesbakery.com

REVIEWS:

“Our wedding cake was beautiful and everything was delicious. Thanks, Aggie and to Alex for all your help and patience.” – Catherine H.

Classy Girl CupcakesTop Cakes in Milwaukee

Classy Girl Cupcakes was started in 2009 by Erica Elia, who prepared cupcakes for her own wedding. Friends and family wanted her to bake for their weddings and celebrations since they were so popular. On November 23, 2010, Classy Girl Cupcakes launched its retail bakery on Jefferson Street, across from Cathedral Square Park, home of Bastille Days and Jazz in the Park, in one of Milwaukee’s most lively districts.

Classy Girl Cupcakes has expanded from one employee to over 25 in just over a year, catering to hundreds of weddings and corporate events as well as serving walk-in clients and special orders.

Products/Services:

Jumbo Filled Cupcakes, Anniversary Cakes, Birthday Cakes, Wedding Cakes

LOCATION:

Address: 825 N Jefferson St, Milwaukee, WI 53202
Phone:
(414) 270-1877
Website:
www.classygirlcupcakes.com

REVIEWS:

“I ordered a small cake for my husband’s birthday and it was beyond perfect. I asked for the cake to be decorated with a lake scene and our two dogs and it was beautiful, better than I could have envisioned. I ordered the strawberry champagne cake and it was delicious. I would 100 percent recommend it. Thank you for this wonderful creation.” – Jacquelyn P.

Scordato Bakery IncCakes Milwaukee

Scordato Bakery Inc creates unique cakes with tasty buttercream or real whip cream frosting for any occasion. By appointment only, a complimentary wedding cake tasting is available. Cakes can be purchased by the slice or as whole cakes on special orders. Adults and children can also use themed décor.

Products/Services:

Cakes for All Occasions

LOCATION:

Address: 5011 W Howard Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53220
Phone: (414) 327-8555
Website: www.scordatobakery.com

REVIEWS:

“Love this place, I always go here for their red velvet macarons. The customer service is always great and you can get a nice bite to eat if you’re hungry.” – Warren P.

Rich’s House of CakesGood Cakes in Milwaukee

Rich’s House of Cakes is a Milwaukee-based, fourth-generation family-owned business dedicated to crafting exceptional cakes. Dave, their current owner, grew up in the Rich’s House of Cakes family company.

At Rich’s, they don’t skimp on quality in favor of lower costs. For your important occasion, you deserve the finest. This is why, instead of using pre-packaged or chemically preserved mixes, they prepare their cakes from scratch, using only the finest all-natural ingredients.

Products/Services:

Tres Leches Cake, Cheesecake, Chocolate Cake, Red Velvet Cake

LOCATION:

Address: 4353 S 27th St, Milwaukee, WI 53221
Phone: (414) 282-0713
Website: www.richscakes.com

REVIEWS:

“The very best cake. Wonderful customer service too. Makes birthday celebrations super delicious, and extra special. Many thanks for all you do.” –Molly S.

National Bakery & DeliOne of the best Cakes in Milwaukee

National Bakery & Deli, Louis Wisniewski launched the company in 1925 in the center of an old Polish neighborhood. National Bakery & Deli has been expanded and modified multiple times since 1991. The second facility in New Berlin opened in 1996.

The bakery is booming with business today, thanks to a mix of hard labor and excellent products, and it’s still grinding out those amazing donuts, cookies, cakes, and pastries, more than 9 decades later. National Bakery & Deli is pleased to announce that it has been chosen Milwaukee’s best bakery.

Products/Services:

Cheesecakes, Filled Coffee Cakes, Apple Cake, Holiday Decorated Cake, Fruit Cake

LOCATION:

Address: 3200 S 16th St, Milwaukee, WI 53215
Phone: (414) 672-1620
Website: www.nationalbaking.com

REVIEWS:

“The staff are kind and very helpful, going above and beyond expectation as to their baseline for every customer. No wonder this place is filled with happy customers all day. The delicious bakery speaks for itself.” – Mark M.