5 Best Sandwich Shops in Omaha, NE

Best Sandwich Shops in Omaha

Below is a list of the top and leading Sandwich Shops in Omaha. To help you find the best Sandwich Shops located near you in Omaha, we put together our own list based on this rating points list.

Omaha’s Best Sandwich Shops:

The top rated Sandwich Shops in Omaha, NE are:

  • Potbelly Sandwich Shop – is known for made-to-order toasted sandwiches
  • Pickleman’s Gourmet Cafe – serves sandwiches along with gourmet pizzas
  • Jersey Mike’s Subs – is an Omaha-based counter-serve sandwich chain
  • Gandolfo’s New York Deli – serving up Omaha’s best sandwich since 2005
  • Which Wich Superior Sandwiches – is known for design-your-own sandwiches

Potbelly Sandwich ShopSandwich Shops in Omaha

Potbelly Sandwich Shop specializes in freshly prepared toasted sandwiches, salads, and baked products. From the comfortable, melty cheese of a toasted sandwich created with love, to famous photographs of Jimi Hendrix shredding a guitar solo at Woodstock, Potbelly is just a wonderful place to be. They’re a first-class business. Without a doubt, they make the best-toasted sandwiches in the universe.

But they do so with a smile. It’s simple when you enjoy what you do: make people happy with delicious food like toasted sandwiches, soups, salads, fresh-baked cookies, and hand-scooped milkshakes. They feel that using simple, high-quality ingredients makes a difference. Potbelly will never cut corners on size or quality.

Products/Services:

Sandwiches, Salads, and Baked Goods

LOCATION:

Address: 2056 N 117th Ave Suite A-1, Omaha, NE 68164
Phone: (402) 916-4513
Website: www.potbelly.com

REVIEWS:

“Hands down the best sandwich I have ever had. The hot peppers are seriously the perfect blend of sweet and hot. The staff was more than helpful and greeted me when I walked in. 700 pm 0129 A++ highly recommended.” – Benjamin J.

Pickleman’s Gourmet CafeTop Sandwich Shops in Omaha

Pickleman’s Gourmet Cafe delivers gourmet sandwiches and salads, as well as custom-made gourmet pizzas and soups, to anywhere in Omaha, NE. They take pride in providing their customers with the best gourmet food around, all delivered promptly and at a reasonable price. Not sure whether you’d prefer soup or a sandwich for lunch? Choose from any two half-servings of any freshly prepared soups, sandwiches, or salads in their pick-two combo. You have tasty sides like chips, pickles, buns, cookies, and peppers.

They recognize how important health is to the consumers, so they only use the freshest products. White or wheat buns are available; please inquire about them, as well as other healthy menu alternatives and replacements.

Products/Services:

Sandwiches, Salads, and Pizzas

LOCATION:

Address: 1503 Farnam St, Omaha, NE 68102
Phone: (402) 505-9775
Website: www.picklemans.com

REVIEWS:

“This place is pretty good! They have really good menu options, the sandwiches are very flavourful, the bread is toasted but not hard. The pizza looks. I’ll be getting that next time. I had the meatball sandwich toasted with garlic butter pepper jack cheese with marinara sauce. I can honestly say better than Subway. The customer service was exceptional as well! I’ll definitely visit again.” – Ny J.

Jersey Mike’s SubsSandwich Shops Omaha

Jersey Mike’s Subs is a counter-serve sandwich shop that specializes in large subs with cold cuts and toppings. Mike’s Subs was founded in 1956 and was initially known as Mike’s Subs. In the beach town of Point Pleasant, New Jersey, Mike built a tiny shop. It’s important to note that there were few franchise restaurants or hamburger franchises in 1956. There are no pizza, chicken, or taco chains, either.

In 1956, entrepreneurs or “mom-and-pop” shops would open their doors in simple storefront settings like this one. To survive and prosper, they needed to provide high-quality products with unmatched customer service. In 1956, Mike was one of a kind because the product he was selling was a relatively new item in American culture: the submarine sandwich.

Products/Services:

Sandwiches, Chips, and Drinks

LOCATION:

Address: 203 N 180th St, Omaha, NE 68118
Phone: (402) 614-1119
Website: www.jerseymikes.com

REVIEWS:

“Delicious! My husband and I kept seeing the commercials for Jersey Mike’s and wanted to give them a try. If you want a sub with plenty of meat on it this is the place to get it. Employees did a great job with our order and we will definitely get takeout from here again.” – Barb W.

Gandolfo’s New York DeliGood Sandwich Shops in Omaha

Gandolfo’s New York Deli has been providing Omaha with the greatest sandwich since 2005. They’ve been a family-run, locally owned business. Every day, the owner can be found at the shops. They also put a strong emphasis on giving back to the Omaha community, which has been essential to company growth over the past 15 years. They do things the deli way, which sets Gandolfo apart from the competition. They prepare their own deli salads, mousse cakes, and sauces from scratch, and they also bake their own bread and freshly slice their own specialty meats, cheeses, and vegetables.

Products/Services:

Sandwiches, Salads, Hotdogs, Sides

LOCATION:

Address: 11901 Pacific St, Omaha, NE 68154
Phone: (402) 614-1135
Website: www.gandolfosomaha.com

REVIEWS:

“I love this place. It is one of the best places here in Omaha to get a worthwhile breakfast sandwich and deli sandwiches. This is called the Crew. It has bacon, sausage, fried egg, and cheese. They are made fresh and every bite is worth the wait.” – Jessica P.

Which Wich Superior SandwichesOne of the best Sandwich Shops in Omaha

Which Wich Superior Sandwiches is a modern, simple sandwich chain that specializes in build-your-own sandwiches and a wide variety of bread alternatives. They feel that a fantastic sandwich has the ability to brighten anyone’s day. Whether you’re looking for a change of pace from your regular lunch routine, a meal that everyone in your company will like, or simply a little bit of comfort, they’re there to help. Each sandwich is handcrafted with care and delivered with a smile and a thank you to send you on your way feeling re-energized and satisfied.

Products/Services:

Sandwiches

LOCATION:

Address: 307 N 114th St, Omaha, NE 68154
Phone: (402) 933-9425
Website: www.whichwich.com

REVIEWS:

“Friendly service. Amazing sandwich. I got the garden party with avocado, cucumber, red onion, iceberg lettuce, melted smoked provolone, and sauce on wheat, BOMB. I devoured my large sandwich like it was nothing. They hooked it up. Thanks, ladies. I didn’t get their names but, they were all sweet and chill.” – Gracie M.