5 Best Sandwich Shops in New York🥇

Below is a list of the top and leading Sandwich Shops in New York. To help you find the best Sandwich Shops located near you in New York, we put together our own list based on this rating points list.

New York’s Best Sandwich Shops:

The top rated Sandwich Shops in New York are:

  • Spreads Sandwich Shop – the answer to everyone’s breakfast and lunch desires
  • Katz’s Delicatessen – family owned and operated for over 100 years
  • Sandwicherie of New York – committed to serving you fresh and healthy meals coupled by a pleasant shopping experience and premium service
  • The Picnic Basket – sandwich shop where freshness makes the difference
  • Bite – provides the best in the city at affordable cost without compromising quality and flavor

Spreads Sandwich Shop

spreads sandwich shop in new york

Spreads Sandwich Shop was built to cater the breakfast and lunch cravings of many. They make sandwiches full of fresh, organic ingredients. Additionally, Spreads not only make sandwiches but they also serve indulgent cakes and delightful pastries. They do all preparations of their products on site. From smoking veggies and meats, making mayo, almond milk and baking pastries are all done on site.

Spreads is the perfect spot for customers who appreciate health-conscious choices, creative recipes and meticulous preparations. Among the sandwiches that they make include Croissant and Egg, Bacon and Egg, Egg and Cheese, Salmon Bagel, and Bagel and Cream Cheese.

Products/Services:

Sandwich Shop, Breakfast, Lunch, Sweets, Salads and Sides, Coffees and Teas

LOCATION:

Address: 441 Park Ave S, New York, NY 10016
Phone: (212) 758 5555
Website: spreadsnyc.com

REVIEWS:

“On a cold and wet New york morning, the croissant and egg sandwich is one to die for. Have it while its fresh out of the oven and savor the gentle dripping egg in the delicate croissant blended perfectly with the right amount of cheese. I might just have it everyday.” – Shrey Gupta

Katz’s Delicatessen

katz's sandwich shop in new york

Katz’s Delicatessen became an inherent part of New York’s history and culture. Lots of customers flock to this restaurant to eat the most delectable meats, platters and especially sandwiches. People even frequently visit for the pastrami on rye.

They built their reputation based on quality of their gourmet. They only choose the finest cuts of beef for brisket, pastrami, corned beef and other foods. In Katz’s, they do not use water, chemicals and other additives to speed up the process of curing the meat. What they do is a slower method the brings out the meat’s best flavor.

Products/Services:

Sandwich Shop

LOCATION:

Address: 205 E Houston St, New York, NY 10002
Phone: (212) 254 2246
Website: katzsdelicatessen.com

REVIEWS:

“This was probably the most amazing and intriguing restaurant that I have ever seen. The fact that very little has changed in 132 years is mind blowing. The tastiest pastrami I’ve ever had. The fresh pickles were amazing, and I’m not really even a big pickle fan. The whole ticket system is a little intimidating at first, but it’s a part of the institution that is Katz’s. I can’t wait to have some of their delicious foods delivered to me all the way in Florida!” – Austin Hatfield

Sandwicherie of New York

sandwicherie sandwich shop in new york

Sandwicherie of New York aims to cater customers with vibrant, natural and healthy lifestyle. They hold to the commitment to prepare and serve healthy and fresh meals. This sandwich shop is operated by talented people that consistently create made-to-order or chef-inspired flavorful sandwiches and salads. Breakfast and lunch meals features wild rice bowls and healthy quinoa, fresh fruit juice as well as a huge variety of desserts and bakery items. As their commitment to quality of their foods, they ensure that ingredient sources are evaluated for nutritional value, taste, safety and freshness.

Products/Services:
Breakfast Grill, Bagel, Soup, Sandwiches, Salads, Signature Bowls, Pressed Juice
LOCATION:
Address: 202 E 42nd St, New York, NY 10017
Phone: (212) 972 5600
Website: sandwicherie.com
REVIEWS:
“Love this place. Their sandwiches, wraps, paninis, salads, whatever you choose, are amazing! Their cheesecakes are huge and also amazing! Lunch in a bag, or to sit down, you must go here. You just must.” – Donna Fidler

The Picnic Basket

the picnic basket sandwich shop in new york

Freshness of products is what The Picnic Basket sets apart. All their ingredients, from breads to cheeses, are delivered on a daily basis. This means that their products are freshly made to the best standard.

Their menu is a combination and unique tastes. In addition, the menu is diverse with flavors adopted from Asian, Italian and Mediterranean traditions. This sandwich shop caters over 15 different kinds of sandwiches in which you can choose the salads and dressings that you prefer, including choices of flavorful soups. The great thing is that all are free from MSG and other preservatives.

Products/Services:

Sandwich Shop, Breakfast, Lunch, Catering

LOCATION:

Address: 65 W 37th St, New York, NY 10018
Phone: (212) 382 2627
Website: tpbnyc.com

REVIEWS:

“Unique options. Good size portions. Expect to pay $15-20 usd for a sandwich, drink and soup. VERY FAST service. Food was tasty. My wife didn’t think her sandwich was good but she’s very picky. We come from a small town in Texas so anything in NY is very different. Highly recommend if you’re looking for a unique food spot out of their comfort zone.” – Pedro Herrejon

Bite

bite sandwich shop in new york

Bite first opened in 2002, in a corner space on Lafayete and Bleecker. The menu that time contains only not more than five sandwiches. Who would expect that this restaurant opened my a formed employee in fashion industry would offer among the most diverse menus in New York.

Bite’s ingredients are simple and fresh, with no preservatives. From bread to cheese to soups and dressings, they are all freshly made. Keeping in mind customer service, they made it a top priority to cater the best service at a reasonable cost without compromising the quality or flavor of products.

Products/Services:

Breakfast, Salads, Sandwiches, Drinks, Sweets and Snacks

LOCATION:

Address: 211 E 14th St, New York, NY 10003
Phone: (212) 677 3123
Website: bitenyc.com

REVIEWS:

“Wonderful experience, quick service and good food for the prices. A friend and I talked about an artist and they played them over speakers. Very friendly service and staff was very caring! Would come again!” – Renee Smith