5 Best Sandwich Shops in Milwaukee, WI

5 Best Sandwich Shops in Milwaukee, WI

Below is a list of the top and leading Sandwich Shops in Milwaukee, WI. To help you find the best Sandwich Shops located near you in Milwaukee, WI, we put together our own list based on this rating points list.

Milwaukee, WI’s Best Sandwich Shops:

The top-rated Sandwich Shops in Milwaukee, WI are:

  • Potbelly Sandwich Shop – retro-style counter-serve chain known for made-to-order toasted sandwiches, salads & baked goods.
  • Jake’s Deli – old-school delicatessen since 1955 for hot corned beef, pastrami & other sandwiches & sides.
  • Jersey Mike’s – New Jersey-based counter-serve sandwich chain serving jumbo subs filled with cold cuts & toppings.
  • Jimmy John’s – counter-serve chain specializing in sub & club sandwiches, plus signature potato chips.
  • Suburpia – we aim for perfection in the products we make and in the service we provide.

Potbelly Sandwich Shop

5 Best Sandwich Shops in Milwaukee, WI

Potbelly Sandwich Shop is one of the best destinations in Milwaukee if you want the best sandwiches. This sandwiches shop has sandwiches, salads, and more. Potbelly Sandwich Shop brings you a wide range of flavors that will surely make your mouth water. You can also mix and match their sandwiches, soups, and salads to make the ultimate combo. They have both an in-shop menu, delivery menu, and catering menu. Some favorites include their Italian sub, powerhouse salad, broccoli cheddar soup, and more. The service is also excellent with their friendly and attentive staff. If you want to experience the best sandwiches in Milwaukee, Potbelly Sandwich Shop is a top option to consider.

Products/Services:
Sandwiches, subs, salads, dessert, merchandise, gift cards

LOCATION:
Address: 135 W Wisconsin Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53203
Phone: (414) 226-0014
Website: potbelly.com

REVIEWS:
Potbelly is my favorite place to eat in the USA. The staff at this store was super nice and friendly. I was greeted by every single employee. There is no parking lot here. You have to find parking on the street. – Amarpreet Sran

Jake’s Deli

The Best Sandwich Shops in Milwaukee, WI

Jake’s Deli is one of the most popular and respected sandwich shops in Milwaukee. This sandwich shop opened its doors in 1955 and has become a tradition in the area. Jake’s Deli specializes in hand-crafted Pastrami and corned beef sandwiches. They also have other very popular food options like soups and salads. This sandwich shop provides the customer with an authentic deli experience. Their staff is very attentive and friendly. They have been working in the industry for years and have the expertise to provide you with an amazing meal. So, if you want to try out one of Milwaukee’s best sandwich shops, Jake’s Deli is up there with the best.

Products/Services:
Sandwiches, subs, salads, dessert, merchandise, gift cards

LOCATION:
Address: 1634 W North Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53205
Phone: (414) 562-1272
Website: jakesdeli1.com

REVIEWS:
Delicious! We had the pastrami sandwich. It was tender and flavorful. Also, huge. This is the sandwich every other sandwich wants to be! Next time I’ll get mine toasted so the bread holds together better. Un-toasted this was a fork sandwich. Potato salad and coleslaw did not disappoint. Highly recommend. – Margaret Namio

Jersey Mike’s

Best Sandwich Shops in Milwaukee, WI

Jersey Mike’s is a counter-serve sandwich shop and one of the most popular shops in the country. This sandwich shop has many branches across the United States. Jersey Mike’s offers dine-in, pick-up, and delivery. You get quality when you dine at Jersey Mike’s. All food options are made fresh from the best ingredients and service. Their staff is made up of customer service professionals. They bring friendliness, experience, and efficiency to make your dining experience amazing. If you want to try out some of the best sandwiches in Milwaukee, Jersey Mike’s is a must-try.

Products/Services:
Sandwiches, subs, salads, dessert, merchandise, gift cards

LOCATION:
Address: 544 East Ogden Ave. Milwaukee, WI 53202-2698
Phone: (414) 539-3253
Website: jerseymikes.com

REVIEWS:
I come here after I volunteer at a dog rescue nearby. The service is always great and employees are always pleasant. Too often these days you get poor service at restaurants, especially fast-food-type places. We made sure to also express our gratitude to the restaurant manager. – Amanda Stengel

Jimmy John’s

Milwaukee, WI Best Sandwich Shops

Jimmy John’s offers some of the best hand-made sandwiches and other snacks in Milwaukee. Each food option you order is made fresh from the best ingredients. Jimmy John’s also has amazing deals like their buy one get one free deal. Their sandwiches don’t only look great, they taste great as well. These sandwiches are made by food artisans that have the experience and knowledge to give you the best meal. The staff is also very friendly and will serve you happily. They will go above and beyond to make sure your dining experience is nothing short of great. So, if you are craving a sandwich, Jimmy John’s is one of the best places you should try out.

Products/Services:
Sandwiches, subs, salads, dessert, merchandise, gift cards

LOCATION:
Address: 1344 E Brady St., Milwaukee, WI 53202
Phone: (414) 272-3333
Website: jimmyjohns.com

REVIEWS:
Once again I had another out-of-the-body-like experience at Club Jimmie John’s on Brady St. My #2 on wheat bread was carefully crafted by what I can only describe as the hands of God Himself. What a blessing it is to live so close to the 8th Wonder of the World. Keep on trucking ladies and gentlemen! – Ryne Pinto

Suburpia

Milwaukee, WI's Best Sandwich Shops

Suburpia is one of the best destinations in Milwaukee for an amazing sandwich experience. This sandwich shop opened in 1967 and hasn’t looked back ever since. Suburpia has maintained its amazing sandwiches and services consistently through the years. Their menu is ever-evolving and brings you amazing options to try out. These sandwiches are hand-crafted by the best sandwich experts. Each order is made fresh from the best ingredients. The service is also amazing with friendly staff members. So, if you want the complete sandwich experience, Suburpia is the place to go.

Products/Services:
Sandwiches, subs, salads, dessert, merchandise, gift cards

LOCATION:
Address: 116 E Layton Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53207
Phone: (414) 727-8300
Website: suburpia.com

REVIEWS:
I loved it as a kid and I still do and the owner was very nice to talk to awesome sandwiches all the oil sauce is what makes the sandwiches I also think it’s great to eat it right from the bag it’s wrapped in no messes I always come back its definitely a 5 star. – Yvonne Jolly