5 Best Pizzeria in Jacksonville 🥇

5 Best Pizzeria in Jacksonville

Below is a list of the top and leading Pizzeria in Jacksonville. To help you find the best Pizzeria located near you in Jacksonville, we put together our own list based on this rating points list.

Jacksonville’s Best Pizzeria:

The top-rated Pizzeria in Jacksonville are:

  • Pieology Pizzeria – chain pizzeria serving oven-fired pies made with a diverse range of sauces, cheeses & toppings.
  • Tony D’s New York Pizza & Restaurant – a relaxed Italian joint specializing in New York-style pizza offers many traditional entrees.
  • Mama Mia’s Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria – easy-going choice for classic pies & a large selection of homestyle Italian mains, plus draft beer.
  • Biggie’s Pizza Jax Beach – late-opening restaurant serving pies & slices in a funky space with a lively atmosphere & takeout.
  • Milano’s Italian Restaurant Pizza and Bar – serves both thin-crust & Sicilian pies, plus subs & other staples.

Pieology Pizzeria

5 Best Pizzeria in Jacksonville

Pieology Pizzeria is a fast-casual pizza franchise that serves quality and fresh pies like their six-crusts pizzas, hearty wheat, pie rise thick, and veggie cauliflower. This pizzeria also has a build your own pizza option where you can choose from a variety of sauces and fresh and all-natural vegetables and meats that can be cooked within ten minutes. You can order online via the PieLife app for delivery or pickup. Besides an amazing collection of pizzas, Pieology also offers appetizers and desserts like gooey garlic bread, and Hershey’s and Reese’s cookies.

Dine-in, curbside pickup, non-contact delivery, kids’ activities, catering.

Address: 4624 Town Crossing Drive Ste 125 Jacksonville, 32246
Phone: (904) 720-4026
Website: pieology.com

Best pizza $10 could buy. Fresh and juicier. I highly recommend it. The staff loves their job and willing to cooperate with you as you place an order. Shalom! – TeeJay Smith

Tony D’s New York Pizza & Restaurant

The Best Pizzeria in Jacksonville

Tony D’s New York Pizza & Restaurant is one of the best pizza places in Jacksonville with their amazing collection of pizzas, they also have a pleasant store with decor and comfortable booths that is perfect for families to dine in for dinners or casual meals. Some of their best-sellers are the meat lover’s pizza, pizza Margherita, and their buffalo wing sandwiches. Aside from the food and ambiance, Tony D’s has some of the best and friendliest staff that greets you with a smile.

Dine-in, curbside pick-up, delivery.

Address: 8358 Point Meadows Dr. Jacksonville, FL 32256
Phone: (904) 322-7051
Website: tdnypizza.com

I love this place!! Chicken wings are not fried but taste sooooooooo good!!!! Can’t find the same one in town! Pizza is good and calamari is good and service is awesome! The friendly server named Kennedy she is super sweet! Definitely will be back again and again! What a happy night! – Sinlam Leung

Mama Mia’s Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria

Best Pizzeria in Jacksonville

Mama Mia’s Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria is an Italian restaurant and pizzeria created from Mama’s personal and secret recipes. Being a family-operated and owned restaurant that offers authentic Italian homemade food, Mama Mia’s provides a homey feel for their customers. The menu not only holds an amazing collection of mouth-watering dishes but is also reasonably priced which is an amazing alternative to expensive restaurants that offer the same quality of food. Among their popular dishes are their Lasagna, Fettuccine Alfredo, Manicotti, Tiramisu, and Veal Parmigiana. Their Jacksonville restaurant is located at BJ’s shopping center between St. John’s Town Center and the beach.

Dine-in, takeaway, delivery.

Address: 12220 Atlantic Blvd UNIT 114, Jacksonville, FL 32225
Phone: (904) 221-1122
Website: mamamiasjax.com

My top place for quality Italian food. You will not be disappointed with the menu and service. Service is typically great. The place has a good feel to it. Reminds me of a place in New York I loved to visit. – D. Huffman

Biggie’s Pizza Jax Beach

Jacksonville Best Pizzeria

Biggie’s Pizza Jax Beach is home to Jacksonville’s biggest pizza slices. They have a wide range of dishes and pizza from Pizza by the Slice, pizza pies, wings, salads, and a huge collection of desserts. This Jacksonville pizza spot has always been a recommended pizza place especially on online recommendation sites for a good reason: They have authentic New York-style pizzas, an amazing location that is easily accessible by anyone, and amazing, friendly, and professional staff. The servers will greet and serve you with a smile as you walk in. You’ll definitely have a food coma after leaving this pizzeria due to their mouth-watering morsels.

Dine-in, takeout, delivery.

Address: 1333 3rd St Nb, Jacksonville Beach, FL 32250
Phone: (904) 853-6327
Website: biggiespizzajax.com

Their pizza comes as close to real New York pie you will find in Jacksonville. HUGE slices, 1 slice equals 2 at most places. Very delicious! – Tim Straight

Milano’s Italian Restaurant Pizza and Bar

Jacksonville's Best Pizzeria

Milano’s Italian Restaurant Pizza and Bar is an Italian restaurant and pizza parlor that has been serving some of the best New York-style pizza to the Jacksonville community since 1998. A family-operated restaurant, Milano’s has been dedicated to serving an amazing and unique food experience to everyone who walks into their door. Their dishes are guaranteed fresh and satisfying even to the most experienced palates. Milano’s menu highlights both contemporary and traditional Sicilian cuisine.

Dine-in, curbside pickup, delivery, catering.

Address: 12620 Beach Blvd, Jacksonville, FL 32246
Phone: (904) 646-9119
Website: milanospizzajax.com

Wow! This restaurant was great and good to visit! The pizza they have has good taste. My friends and I went there on the weekend, and we have a great time with each other. We love the place. It was stylish and comfortable to stay with. The staff was also entertaining. He was wearing a smile when he was serving customers like us. – Brian Kirklan