5 Best Italian Restaurants in Milwaukee, WI

Best Italian Restaurants in Milwaukee

Below is a list of the top and leading Italian Restaurants in Milwaukee. To help you find the best Italian Restaurants located near you in Milwaukee, we put together our own list based on this rating points list.

Milwaukee’s Best Italian Restaurants:

The top rated Italian Restaurants in Milwaukee, WI are:

  • Tua Pasta Milwaukee – is a restaurant that serves fresh pasta made in-house every day by its crew
  • Carini’s Southern Italian Restaurant – is the well-guarded hidden on Milwaukee’s East Side
  • Tenuta’s Italian Restaurant – was established by Cesare and Antonia Tenuta after they transferred from the southern tip of Italy to America
  • Santino’s Little Italy – flourish to be the finest that Milwaukee has to present
  • Marsel’s Italian Restaurant – is among the finest Italian restaurants in Milwaukee, WI

Tua Pasta MilwaukeeItalian Restaurants in Milwaukee

Tua Pasta Milwaukee is a restaurant that serves fresh pasta made in-house every day by its crew. They believe in the significance of the visitors’ choices and they made a menu that values the guest’s freedom to select what they wish. That is why they look for quality elements as fresh as possible to secure they provide a quality product that visitors enjoy.

They are a family-managed restaurant that was made in Milwaukee. They help native producers and enterprises to aid encourage their local economy. They believe that by making individuals happy with the food, they can cause their day well. They feel good about their concept and the goods they serve, which is why they have an open-style kitchen. Their visitors are capable to see how they make the pasta, the quality of their produce, and the clean area in which they work.

Products/Services:

Food Menu, Order Online, Dine-In

LOCATION:

Address: 100 E Wisconsin Ave LL101, Milwaukee, WI 53202
Phone: (414) 988 4016
Website: www.tuapastatp.com

REVIEWS:

“ Great concept! Great for vegans and vegetarians too since there are plenty of sauce and topping options. Quick and friendly service and big portions if you choose largely. Definitely, an awesome option if you like pasta.” – Monali P.

Carini’s Southern Italian RestaurantTop Italian Restaurants in Milwaukee

Carini’s Southern Italian Restaurant is the well-guarded hidden on Milwaukee’s East Side, and today a part of your family since 1996. The warmth of a bonfire, the smell of garlic, the pleasing noises of Italian classics, everything as you walk in. Chef-proprietor Peter Carini arrived in the U.S. in 1966 from Porticello, a little fishing village around Palermo, Sicily, where he learned from his mother that fine Italian food is equipped by taste, touch, and heart. Peter also carried to America a wonderful awareness of seafood. The cuisine is separately prepared in an easy way using the freshest foods and the best ingredients.

Products/Services:

Menu, Catering, Party Room, Dine-In

LOCATION:

Address: 3468 N Oakland Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53211
Phone: (414) 963 9623
Website: www.atouchofsicily.com

REVIEWS:

“I have nothing but great things to say for this family-run business. I highly recommend as they had both phenomenal service and food. They do a good job of ensuring each guest has an amazing experience. I had the best creamy pesto pasta I’ve ever had!! Lisa, our waitress, was super helpful and the head chef is truly gifted. A good place to go for family, friends, or date night.” – Sammie H.

Tenuta’s Italian RestaurantItalian Restaurants Milwaukee

Tenuta’s Italian Restaurant was established by Cesare and Antonia Tenuta after they transferred from the southern tip of Italy to America. Delivering with them an abundance of great handcrafted cooking instructions and concepts, the Tenutas decided to share their enthusiasm for quality food with the wonderful people in and around Bayview and started Tenuta’s Italian Restaurant.

Currently, you can try a great variety of traditional dishes in an alluring and consoling environment. From private dinners to corporate work parties, they want to be a part of your life daily. When they say from their family to yours, they mean it.

Products/Services: 

Menu, Catering, Gift Cards, Dine-In

LOCATION:

Address: 2995 S Clement Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53207
Phone: (414) 431 1014
Website: www.tenutasitalian.com

REVIEWS:

“Great Italian-American Restaurant snuggled in a quiet neighborhood in Bay View. Everything was great from start to finish. The food was fresh and prepared to the proper textures (pasta) wine was a great compliment. The staff was friendly and prompt. It was a very enjoyable evening out. Make a reservation! Walk-ins are hard-pressed to find a table. Call ahead! Can’t wait to return.” – Jennifer R.

Santino’s Little ItalyGood Italian Restaurants in Milwaukee

Santino’s Little Italy flourish to be the finest that Milwaukee has to present. They only use the finest and latest ingredients and utilize domestic sources of foods and products. Santino’s uses only the best. They apply Caputo 00 flour, Grande mozzarella, and San Marzano tomatoes. Newly cut cherry wood from northern Wisconsin finishes the procedure that will leave your taste buds watering. Patio seating is accessible and they are situated on the same street as the well-known Barnacle Buds.

Products/Services:

Menu, Drinks, Order Online, Dine-In

LOCATION:

Address: 352 E Stewart St, Milwaukee, WI 53207
Phone: (414) 897 7367
Website: www.santinoslittleitaly.com

REVIEWS:

“Really tasty Italian food! They have a lot of authentic pizza options and the one I had was delicious. I also tried the fried calamari and it was super good too. Highly recommended.” – Danny C.

Marsel’s Italian RestaurantOne of the best Italian Restaurants in Milwaukee

Marsel’s Italian Restaurant is among the finest Italian restaurants in Milwaukee, WI. They mean to provide true Italian food done from farm-fresh ingredients. They are a small family-managed company formed in 2011; that has an enthusiasm for amazing food, service, and a cozy atmosphere where relationships are made and handled like family.

They believe in applying fresh produce to produce their dishes from scratch and signature sauces that are like none other. Using word of mouth and dedication to making delicious food, hosting activities, and a cozy atmosphere Marsel’s has become one of the dearly loved restaurants in Milwaukee.

Products/Services:

Restaurant Menu, Dine-In, Lunch, Dinner

LOCATION:

Address: 4252 S Howell Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53207
Phone: (414) 763 0033
Website: www.marselsitalianrestaurant.com

REVIEWS:

“Enjoyed excellent meals and warm, attentive service. Will be back for sure, with guests. Pleased to know the former Dino’s has been remade into a charming new neighborhood go-to. Three of us had Italian specialties that were fresh and well-prepared and every bit as good if not better than at other more expensive restaurants. Included choices of homemade soups or colorful salad… also offer pizza and burgers on the menu.” – Donna G.