5 Best Caterers in New York 🥇

5 Best Caterers in New York

Below is a list of the top and leading Caterers in New York. To help you find the best Caterers located near you in New York, we put together our own list based on this rating points list.

New York’s Best Caterers:

The top-rated Caterers in New York are:

  • Bartleby & Sage – one of New York City’s top events & catering companies
  • Abigail Kirsch Catering – go-to events and catering company that provides in-house and outside venues
  • Amy Ruth’s Harlem – chicken & waffles place that serve soul food and offers catering services
  • Bistro Caterers – offers breakfast, lunch, and dinner catering options for pick up or delivery
  • Deborah Miller Catering & Events – one of the top catering companies in NYC that boasts a huge clientele

Bartleby & Sage

best caterers in NYC

Bartleby & Sage is not only one of the top events and catering companies in New York City, but they have won awards as well. They specialize in international sustainable dishes from around the world. The company has been featured in various shows and publications like The Food Network and The Today Show for their delectable and ground-breaking cuisine.

Leslie Nilsson, who founded Sage is one of the top players in New York’s events scene and the company has become the go-to choice for politicians, celebrities, and major corporations.

Products/Services:

Sustainable Catering and Events Planning

LOCATION:

Address: 630 Flushing Avenue, Fifth Floor, Brooklyn, NY 11206
Phone: (212) 888-2664
Website: bartlebyandsage.com 

REVIEWS:

We hired Bartleby & Sage to cater to our 200+ person, brunch wedding in Brooklyn. Rachael was our point person and she was amazing to work with. She understood our vision and put together a menu proposal that was exactly what we wanted. Their team is creative and talented. The food was delicious and looked amazing. We can’t say enough good things about them and are hoping to attend future events catered by them! – Dale Levine

Abigail Kirsch Catering

NYC best catering

Abigail Kirsch Catering handles several New York Metro event venues that provide catering both in-house and at a client’s venue. They have a good selection of predesigned menus for lunches, dinners, and corporate events.

The catering company has also been regarded as one of NYC’s leading events and cuisine juggernauts, having been featured in high-profile publications like HuffPost Weddings, Catering, Stamford, GQ, Bizbash, among others.

Products/Services:

Exclusive Venues, Off-Premises Catering, Events

LOCATION:

Address: 71 W 23rd St #1611, New York, NY 10010
Phone: (212) 696-4076
Website: abigailkirsch.com

REVIEWS:

The most amazing wedding venue ever. We got married here this past weekend and it was unbelievable. The food was amazing. The service was incredible. Everything was perfect. They really know what they are doing there. The compliments just keep coming. Cannot even find the words to describe how amazing everything was. Wish I could do it all again next weekend!!!! – Jessica R.

Amy Ruth’s Harlem

best caterers in new york

Amy Ruth’s Harlem was initiated in Harlem back in 1998. They are a chicken and waffles joint that also offers catering services for customers in New York. Owner Carl S. Redding made sure to fill up his menu with soul food recipes that he inherited from his grandma, Amy Ruth. 

They offer a wide range of menu options for catering including breakfast and lunch buffets, along with lunch options like catfish, ribs, fried chicken, and a myriad of desserts and sides.

Products/Services: 

Catering, Private Parties, Dine In/Take Out

LOCATION:

Address: 113 West 116th Street Harlem, New York 10026
Phone: (212) 280-8779
Website: amyruths.com

REVIEWS:

Stupid good. Real welcoming from the get-go. We asked what was recommended and our server told us the waffles and fried chicken was their signature. I’m not big on chicken and waffles so I went for 2eggs, fried chicken and potatoes. I figured I best make sure I didn’t like the chicken and waffles so I tried my partners, what a fool I am!!! So good it’s stupid. I’m gonna stop the search right here, the fried chicken is that good!! I’m coming back for dinner, tonight. – Thom M.

Bistro Caterers

new york city caterers

Bistro Caterers has been providing quality breakfast, lunch, and dinner catering options for clients since 2003. Customers can either pick up their orders from their Lexington Avenue branch or order via phone or the mobile app Seamless. 

Their catering services boast a sizeable clientele, serving hundreds of people every single day for their events, corporate meetings, and private parties with their amazing customer service.

Products/Services:

Catering, Events, Delivery

LOCATION:

Address: 333 East 23rd Street, New York, NY 10010
Phone: (212) 808-4200
Website: bistrocaterers466.com

REVIEWS:

This place is a hidden gem in the area and my go-to for salads. With so many expensive lunch options around Grand Central, it feels so comforting to know that this place is around to save that hole in your wallet. – Samantha T.

Deborah Miller Catering & Events

NYC best catering service

Deborah Miller Catering & Events considers themself as a “big city, homemade business” that prides on passion and hard work on what they do. Founder Deborah Miller is a culinary savant that has traveled across Europe to learn various types of cuisine. Now, the catering company has produced elegant dishes for a variety of events throughout the years and has maintained its quality standards.

The company also has a huge client base from a wide range of industries like television networks, law firms, and production companies. Among their biggest clients are ABC, ESPN, Facebook, FOX, BBC, Google, Yahoo, Turner Broadcasting, Coca-Cola, among others.

Products/Services:

Catering, Corporate, Weddings, Socials

LOCATION:

Address: 3 Madison St, New York, NY 10038
Phone: (212) 964-1300
Website: deborahmillercatering.com

REVIEWS:

Jennifer Burns and the DMC crew did a great job helping us with our End of Summer Soirée. Our team was pleased with the quality of the service as well as the food! – Hakim Myers