5 Best Cakes in New York 🥇

5 Best Cakes in New York

Below is a list of the top and leading Cakes in New York. To help you find the best Cakes located near you in New York, we put together our own list based on this rating points list.

New York’s Best Cakes:

The top-rated Cakes in New York are:

  • City Cakes – high-end cake shop that offers a wide array of basic and customized cakes and other pastries
  • Bon Vivant New York – popular luxury dessert place in NYC
  • Soma Cakes – one of the best cakes and pastry studios that do custom orders for clients
  • Empire Cake – a retro-style bakery that serves homemade cakes and coffee
  • Magnolia Bakery – the go-to place for German chocolate cakes in New York

City Cakes

best cakes in new york

City Cakes has been known for making custom cakes in New York for over thirteen years now. Opening back in 2007, the shop prides itself on having unique and clean designs that not only look aesthetically pleasing but also leave memorable flavors in any customer’s palate.

A high-end cake shop, City Cakes gets inspiration for their beautiful edible masterpieces from New York City’s diverse cultural melting pot and provide clients with a wide array of pastries like their gourmet cupcakes, Half Pound Cookies, which, by the way, is considered to be some of the world’s tastiest treats.

Products/Services:

Basic and customized cakes, pastries for any occasion, cake design classes 

LOCATION:

Address: Lower Level, 251 W 18th St, New York, NY 10011
Phone: (646) 688-2286
Website: citycakes.com

REVIEWS:

City Cakes is THE absolute best when it comes to sweets and people. I came here the first time I visited NYC after they reached out to me on Instagram as a place to visit. Let me tell you, these cookies are no joke, easily the softest, tastiest cookies I’ve ever had. On top of all that, they have the sweetest staff! If you’re in the area or require a sweet online delivery, I highly recommended City Cakes to everyone and anyone. – Sierra St. Pierre

Bon Vivant New York

best luxury cakes in New York City

Bon Vivant New York was founded after Maya Hormis left her 17-year corporate career after being inspired by one of Steve Jobs’ speeches that led her to pursue her passion of pastry-making. Maya’s affinity for detail and elegance has led Bon Vivant to be recognized for having some of the best-made cakes in NYC. Florence Fabricant of the New York Times even stated that Bon Vivant’s cakes are “elegant flavors packed in a square inch”.

The cake shop also touts an impressive clientele, having the likes of Louis Vuitton, Tiffany & Co, Cartier, and a long list of celebrities, NYC’s elite and high-profile fashion editors.

Products/Services:

Miniature cakes and petit fours

LOCATION:

Address: 231 E 58th St, New York, NY 10022
Phone: (646) 481-4044
Website: bonvivantnewyork.com

REVIEWS:

Very cozy and atmospheric place but a little bit tiny. They have Julius Meiln coffee from Austria. The cakes are just a piece of art with fancy flavor and taste deliciously. Nice experience. – Galyna Shulimova

Soma Cakes

NYC Best Cakes

Soma Cakes was conceptualized by famous custom cake designer and pastry chef Hiroyo Kuramata. Having worked with some of the world’s most iconic chefs like Iron Chef Masaharu Morimoto and renowned pastry chef Eric Bedoucha, Hiroyo was able to gain experience and improve and refine her cake sculpting skills and create works of art that people enjoy today.

Soma’s cakes are considered to be some of the best in New York, specifically their customized cakes that project the client’s exact needs.

Products/Services:

Custom cakes and pastries

LOCATION:

Address: 380 E 10th St, New York, NY 10009
Phone: (212) 388-1801
Website: somacakesnyc.com

REVIEWS:

Soma cakes is very professional. They respond quickly to emails and their cakes are delicious. I ordered a strawberry shortcake for my friends’ birthday to be delivered. They showed up on time and the cake looked exactly the way we wanted. I had no issues and definitely will be ordering from them again. I am so pleased. – M. Louis

Empire Cake

New York City best cakes

Empire Cake provides customers with the best of American baking sprinkled with a gourmet twist. They feature freshly-baked cakes, cookies, pastries, brownies, and a more refined variety of classic treats like Swiss rolls and twinkies. Empire also makes custom-ordered cakes and touts every creation as one-of-a-kind for every customer that walks in.

The bakeshop prides itself on providing its clientele with freshly made treats on a daily basis and is made from the best ingredients like cream and butter that they get from quality local producers.

Products/Services:

Freshly-baked cakes and pastries, customized cakes for any occasion

LOCATION:

Address: 112 8th Ave, New York, NY 10011
Phone: (212) 242-5858
Website: empirecake.com

REVIEWS:

We had a great experience with Empire Cake. They were really easy to work with, given that I was planning my New York wedding from Texas. Jessica was transparent with our pricing options and did her best to accommodate our budget. She was extremely responsive to my emails and if she wasn’t around, someone was always informing me of when I was going to get a response. I was so happy with my wedding cake. We also had Empire do our favors (black and white cookies) and everyone loved them! – Shannon C

Magnolia Bakery

Cakes in New York City

Magnolia Bakery opened its first shop back in 1996. The West Village bakery was beloved for its charming and classic interior atmosphere that perfectly complements their amazing collection of baked goods. Their banana pudding, German chocolate cakes, and even their classic chocolate and vanilla cupcakes are to die for.

The bakery has been a cornerstone bakeshop not only in New York but around the world, having multiple branches across the globe in countries like Dubai, Doha, and Manila.

Products/Services:

Classic desserts, variety cupcakes

LOCATION:

Address: 1240 6th Ave, New York, NY 10020
Phone: (212) 767-1123
Website: magnoliabakery.com

REVIEWS:

The world-famous banana pudding was everything I hoped it would be and more. Like heaven in a little tub. I’m glad they ran out of the large sizes by the time I got there. I’m pretty sure I would’ve eaten it all! I’ll definitely go back the next time I’m in NYC. So excited to see they’ve opened a Boston location! – Jamie Pappas