5 Best Cakes in Columbus 🥇

5 Best Cakes in Columbus

Below is a list of the top and leading Cakes in Columbus. To help you find the best Cakes located near you in Columbus, we put together our own list based on this rating points list.

Columbus’s Best Cakes:

The top-rated Cakes in Columbus are:

  • Piece of Cake – easygoing bakery & cafe offering made-to-order cakes & ready-made pastries, plus sandwiches.
  • Kittie’s Cakes – contemporary counter-serve featuring classic & specialty baked goods such as scones & mini cupcakes.
  • Resch’s Bakery – old-school outfit serving cakes, pies, breads, donuts & desserts in a quaint storefront setting.
  • Pattycake Bakery – quaint bakery offering handcrafted cookies, cakes & other sweets with vegan & organic ingredients.
  • The Suisse Shop Bakery – time-tested, local bakeshop featuring specialty cakes, cookies & other desserts in a simple space.

Piece of Cake

5 Best Cakes in Columbus

Piece of Cake‘s goal is to share their love and passion for creating good-looking and delicious food alongside top-level customer service. The shop offers a wide variety of cakes for all occasions. They also have a large collection of cupcakes, cookies, and sweets made from locally-sourced ingredients to support their community. They have a team of amazing bakers and chefs that craft these delectable eats through their experiences and expertise. if you are looking for a cake for a special occasion like birthdays, weddings, and such, or just want to satisfy your sweet tooth, Piece of Cake should be on your shortlist of cake shops.

Cakes, cupcakes, weddings, assorted sweets

Address: 772 N High St, Columbus, OH 43215
Phone: (614) 421-0399
Website: shortnorthpieceofcake.com

Great selection and great price point for pastries and cakes. I always stop by here on my way home too. Fast and efficient service. Large-sized pastries that are delicious. Highly recommend. Everything is delicious. – Tracey Pittman

Kittie’s Cakes

The Best Cakes in Columbus

Kittie’s Cakes is proud of offering unique twists and takes on cakes and sweets that the entire family loves. This cake and bake shop makes all their bites from scratch with the best locally-sourced ingredients. Kittie’s prides itself on being able to create magic through balancing flavor and the nostalgia that traditional cakes and desserts create some of the most amazing and delectable sweets you will ever experience the tasting. If you are looking to satisfy your sweet tooth or need a cake for a special occasion, Kittie’s should have what you need at friendly prices.

Cakes, cupcakes, pastries, cookies, breakfast, lunch, snacks, drinks

Address: 495 S 3rd St, Columbus, OH 43215
Phone: (614) 754-8828
Website: kittiescakes.com

Kittie’s made our client gifts this year. They were perfect. The presentation was beautiful and the cookies were delicious. They were great at communicating and have wonderful customer service. – Brittany Tutwiler

Resch’s Bakery

Best Cakes in Columbus

Resch’s Bakery is a very popular bakeshop in Columbus that uses only the best ingredients to offer their large clientele the best-baked goods available. The most important ingredient to Resch’s is customer satisfaction, which is the focal point of this bakeshop’s operation. Their bakers and chefs are also some of the best and most experienced in the state, being able to craft not only delicious cakes and sweets but aesthetically pleasing baked goods as well. If you are looking for some of the best desserts, cakes, and donuts in Columbus, Resch’s Bakery is where the party is at!

Cakes, cookies, cupcakes, donuts, holiday dessert specials

Address: 4061 E. Livingston Ave. Columbus, Ohio 43227
Phone: (614) 237-7421
Website: reschbakery.com

This bakery is on the other side of town for me, but they never disappoint!! My new favorite, their crescent-shaped doughnuts!! I always get a cake just because they are wonderful! – Trivia Thomas

Pattycake Bakery

Columbus Best Cakes

Pattycake Bakery creates some of the most beautiful and delicious hand-crafted sweets in Columbus. The baking savants at Pattycake create everything from scratch from the best and freshest, locally-sourced ingredients available. They use organic, vegan, and GMO-free ingredients that check off every item on a health nut’s checklist. Popular items are their coconut cloud cake, their chocolate cake, vanilla sprinkle cake, and their caramel salted Pisces cake. If you want a healthier option for your sweets and desserts, Pattycake Bakery has everything that will satisfy your sweet tooth.

Cakes, handcrafted sweets

Address: 3009 N. High St. Columbus, OH 43202
Phone: (614) 784-2253
Website: pattycakebakery.com

Ordered a chocolate cake for my girlfriends’ birthday on the same day. I ordered online very easily and waited two hours. The cake was ready when I arrived and was super easy to social distance pick up. The cake was awesome! I do recommend this place. I’ll be ordering again for sure. – Kyle Weddington

The Suisse Shop Bakery

Columbus's Best Cakes

The Suisse Shop Bakery is an award-winning bakeshop located in Columbus, Ohio. This family-owned and run bakery has been serving the community of Columbus since 1983. If you are craving some cake, cupcake, or other tasty treats, you probably have heard and experienced their delectable sweets. For over thirty years, The Suisse Shop has been sharing their delectable European pastries and baked goods to the public that has grown to love them. Their chefs and bakers have some of the most delicious and intriguing takes on favorite desserts like their cheesecakes, cinnamon rolls, chocolate cakes, and more.

Cakes, cupcakes, party trays, seasonal items

Address: 2119 Polaris Pkwy, Columbus, OH, 43240
Phone: (614)846-5102
Website: thesuisseshop.com

We LOVED our cake! We got so many compliments about it! It went perfectly with our theme! The look was awesome. The flavor was flawless and the buttercream was SOOO smooth. I wouldn’t have changed a thing about it! Get your cake here you won’t regret it! – Ashley Clifford