5 Best Bakeries in Milwaukee, WI

Best Bakeries in Milwaukee, WI

Below is a list of the top and leading Bakeries in Milwaukee, WI. To help you find the best Bakeries located near you in Milwaukee, WI, we put together our own list based on this rating points list.

Milwaukee, WI’s Best Bakeries:

The top-rated Bakeries in Milwaukee, WI are:

  • Scordato Bakery – known for its Christmas cookies and Italian cookies
  • Black Twig Bakery – offers a unique menu every month
  • Rocket Baby Bakery – specializes in artisanal bread, pastries, and sandwiches
  • Simma’s Bakery – opened its doors to the community in 1982
  • Peter Sciortino Bakery – serves fresh baked goods in Milwaukee

Scordato Bakery

Scordato Bakery in Milwaukee, WI

Scordato Bakery is one of the best bakeries in your locale. They are highly known for their Italian cookies, especially their Christmas cookies. Their pastries and cakes are for all occasions, and everything is perfect for sweetening your next special event. For more than a decade, they have provided delicious and memorable baked goods to their surrounding areas. Every cookie is different and unique in its own flavor and design. Hence, there is always something for you in this bakery. Moreover, they have cakes that are customized for every occasion. You may check out their website to see the variety of their cookies and cakes.

Products/Services:

Italian Cookies, Cakes, Baked Goods

LOCATION:

Address: 5011 W Howard Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53220

Phone: (414) 327 8555

Website: scordatobakery.com

REVIEWS:

“Best bakery in the state. Very friendly people. Good variety.” – Susie S.

Black Twig Bakery

Black Twig Bakery in Milwaukee, WI

Black Twig Bakery has one of the best cupcakes and cookies near you. They are a unique bakery shop full of passion and style that invites you to come often. If you are a sweet tooth and like to have delicious cookies or mouth-watering macarons and cookies, you are at the right place. Furthermore, they rotate their menu every month. Hence, you can have different flavors every month, and you might even find your favorite baked goods! In addition, they offer custom cookies and cupcakes for your special party or event.

Products/Services:

Cupcakes, Cookies, Macarons

LOCATION:

Address: 1455 Underwood Ave Wauwatosa, WI 53213

Phone: (414) 231 3327

Website: blacktwigbakery.com

REVIEWS:

“I love everything I’ve tried at this bakery, especially the ice cream sandwiches. The house sugar cookie is also delicious. I definitely suggest checking this place out if you are in the mood for a sweet treat.

The location itself is charming and chic. They have great COVID safety protocols, which I always appreciate!” – Nichole F.

Rocket Baby Bakery

Rocket Baby Bakery in Milwaukee, WI

Rocket Baby Bakery is a one-stop-shop for your memorable afternoon tea moment or a quick brunch during the day. They offer a variety of baked goods such as artisanal bread, pastries, and sandwiches. Everything they offer is made fresh and daily. In addition, they have various coffee and teas to complement your chosen bread, sandwich, or pastry. Their baked goods are made from scratch, and they use ingredients from local markets, ensuring the high quality their customers deserve. A café and a bakery in one location, you will find a variety of delicious baked goods, savory pizza, and fulfilling soup every day.

Products/Services:

Baked Goods, Sandwiches, Coffee

LOCATION:

Address: 6822 W North Ave Wauwatosa, WI 53213

Phone: (414) 502 7323

Website: rocketbabybakery.com

REVIEWS:

“This bakery was INCREDIBLE. The outdoor space was beautiful, too! It’s located right off North Ave in the cute Tosa neighborhood. I got a coffee, an egg sandwich, a cheddar and chive croissant, AND the raspberry croissant. Yes, I absolutely went overboard – but it was COMPLETELY worth it.

Everything was fresh and so full of flavor. My mouth is watering just thinking about it!

The staff was also friendly and quick! This is an order at the window and take-your-meal-to-the-patio type of place, perfect for what I was looking for!

Unfortunately, the only photo I have is from Instagram. Featuring a Cold brew coffee, cheddar & chive Croissant & Raspberry croissant!” – Andrea P.

Simma’s Bakery

Simma's Bakery in Milwaukee, WI

Simma’s Bakery was established in 1982 and opened their doors to the community, sharing their unique and memorable baked goods. For more than 32 years, they served the surrounding communities with their delicious pastries and a good variety of baked goods. They are famous for their iconic and award-winning cheesecake. If you are craving a cheesecake that melts in your mouth, then go to this place. Moreover, they create extraordinary wedding cakes in your locale. A special day is perfect to partner with a special cake. Hence, Simma’s Bakery is your go-to place for cheesecakes and specialty desserts.

Products/Services:

Cheesecake, Cake, Pastries, Baked Goods

LOCATION:

Address: 817 N 68th St, Wauwatosa, WI 53213

Phone: (414) 257 0998

Website: simmasbakery.com

REVIEWS:

“Their cheesecake never disappoints, but don’t sleep on their other bakery items. We ordered a cake for my sister’s baby shower, and it was so good that it brought tears to my friend’s eyes. Thank you to the good people at Simma’s for all that you do.” – Emily M.

Peter Sciortino Bakery

Peter Sciortino Bakery in Milwaukee, WI

Peter Sciortino Bakery only serves fresh baked goods to their customers. They ensure that every piece of baked good they create daily is fresh and delicious by making them from scratch every day. Their baked goods include but are not limited to Italian bread, cakes, rolls, cookies, and pastries. Furthermore, they deliver to your home, or you can pick your order in their store that smells like a delicious baked good. They offer special orders and wholesale for individuals and restaurants. Hence, they strive to bring the best-baked goods and quality service to all of their customers.

Products/Services:

Loaves, Rolls, Cookies, Pastries

LOCATION:

Address: 1101 E Brady St, Milwaukee, WI 53202

Phone: (414) 272 4623

Website: petersciortinosbakery.com

REVIEWS:

“I have been coming to this bakery for over 55 years!” – Kelli L.