5 Best Bagel Shops in Milwaukee, WI

Best Bagels in Milwaukee

Below is a list of the top and leading Bagel Shops in Milwaukee. To help you find the best Bagel Shops located near you in Milwaukee, we put together our own list based on this rating points list.

Milwaukee’s Best Bagel Shops:

The top rated Bagel Shops in Milwaukee, WI are:

  • Ruby’s Bagels – is Milwaukee’s first bagel Pop Up
  • Allie Boy’s Bagelry & Luncheonette – a modern Midwestern bagel shop
  • Einstein Bros. Bagels – serves gourmet bagels baked fresh
  • Colectivo Coffee – serving locally roasted coffee & light eats such as bagel
  • Ma Fischer’s – serving a varied menu of American breakfast & comfort-food dishes

Ruby’s BagelsBagel Shops in Milwaukee

Ruby’s Bagels is Milwaukee’s first bagel Pop Up, which opened in 2019. They are committed to offering the greatest quality bagels as well as a one-of-a-kind experience for their customers. Daniela Ruby Varela founded the company after discovering the most delicious bagel in Ohio and teaching herself how to make it. At the end of 2017, she created her own recipe.

She noticed that such a common breakfast item was lacking in Milwaukee. She looked for a commercial kitchen in 2018 but was unsuccessful until January of 2019 when she started doing Pop Ups at a local Makers Market in Walkers Point and Pilcrow Coffee.

Products/Services:

Bagel Shop

LOCATION:

Address: 636 S 6th St, Milwaukee, WI 53204
Website: www.rubysbagels.com

REVIEWS:

“Immensely delicious bagels – their Rosemary Sea Salt bagels are what I look forward to at the end of the week. I used to think I couldn’t find a consumable bagel in Milwaukee and claimed them to be a “vacation food”, but Ruby’s has gone above and beyond and is absolutely worth the stop. Get a Rosemary Sea Salt with Jalapeño spread, you’ll thank me later.” – Lydia K.

Allie Boy’s Bagelry & LuncheonetteTop Bagel Shops in Milwaukee

Allie Boy’s Bagelry & Luncheonette is a synthesis of our experiences in life, travel, culture, upbringing, and soul. They look forward to inviting you to their Middle Eastern-inspired peace mash-up of fresh hand-rolled Bagels, smoked salmon, and lovingly designed delectable dishes and smorgasbords.

Stop in for a quick baker’s dozen to-go or linger over a smoked fish bagel tower and a bottle of bubbly. Allie Boy’s will be there for you no matter where you come from or where you call home. It’s ready to go, straight from their deli and into your stomach.

Products/Services:

Bagel Shop

LOCATION:

Address: 135 E National Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53204
Phone:
(414) 988-0388
Website:
www.allieboysmke.com

REVIEWS:

“We called Allie Boys to discuss a 40 person breakfast event on very short notice. Staci was fantastic, providing us recommendations for a delightful spread of food and coffee. She made the process so easy and stress-free, and man did they deliver! We had guests from all over the country, and nearly every single person pulled me aside to rave about the quality of the bagels and other food items! Many thanks to Staci and Allie Boys. Do consider them for your event-hosting needs.” – Barry R.

Einstein Bros. BagelsBagel Shops Milwaukee

Einstein Bros. Bagels is a local bagel store. They take pride in serving freshly baked bagels, breakfast sandwiches, lunch sandwiches, coffee, catering, and much more to their clients. Come in and say hello. They will have a fresh bagel and a cup of coffee waiting for you. Every Einstein Bros. Bagels store has a head baker who ensures that each bagel is prepared to perfection. They’re the kitchen’s commanding officers.

Products/Services:

Bagels and Sandwiches

LOCATION:

Address: 3129 S 27th St, Milwaukee, WI 53215
Phone: (414) 385-9888
Website: www.einsteinbros.com

REVIEWS:

“They have an Ancient grain bagel that is amazing. I have not seen those anywhere else. The vanilla hazelnut is my go-to coffee. My favorite bagel was with Nutella, bananas, and almonds. I love this place because they are quick and you get a breakfast that will keep you full for a long time, and the grain or power proteins bagel is a better breakfast.” – Olivia B.

Colectivo CoffeeGood Bagel Shops in Milwaukee

Colectivo Coffee has been importing coffees from origin and carefully roasting each batch since 1993. In addition to Letterbox Fine Tea, they are happy to offer their Session Roasted coffees. They also make all of their own baked goods and savory dishes from scratch at their own Troubadour Bakery, which is open daily.

Products/Services:

Bagels and Coffee

LOCATION:

Address: 2301 S Kinnickinnic Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53207
Phone: (414) 744-6117
Website: www.colectivocoffee.com

REVIEWS:

“This cafe is full of love in all their bread and pastries. Refine and refresh location for the city of Milwaukee, WI aside from the great delicious food.” – Anthony M.

Ma Fischer’sOne of the best Bagel Shops in Milwaukee

Ma Fischer’s had two booths, 16 stools, and an upstairs home. Their crew consisted of two servers, her mother, who served as hostess, and her father, who served as chef and short-order cook. The restaurant has been refurbished four times in the last 40 years, which has contributed to its success. They expanded to 11 booths, six tables, and a counter in the early 1980s.

They eventually erected an atrium, which allowed for an additional 12 tables. They closed for three months in 1989, gutted the restaurant, and rebuilt to their current size. Their menu has remained simple over the years, and they have always attempted to please all palates with a range of options at all hours of the day.

Products/Services:

Bagel, Croissant, Pancakes, Burrito, and More

LOCATION:

Address: 2214 N Farwell Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53202
Phone: (414) 271-7424
Website: www.mafischers.com

REVIEWS:

“Came from Chicago, IL and tried this place with little expectations, but they really knocked it out of the park for a big breakfast for 2 for about $33 plus tip which included 2 entries, 2 coffees, and 2 biscuits on the side. I made my own sandwich with a biscuit and I’m still drooling over it. We were greeted, seated, and treated quickly to an awesome experience. They clean up the place well and promptly, bathrooms are tidy, waitresses friendly and helpful, food came out within 15 min, and our coffee and water were always topped off by the staff. I highly recommend this place! We will definitely return.” – George Z.