HomeIndianapolis, IN5 Best Bakeries in Indianapolis 🥇

5 Best Bakeries in Indianapolis 🥇

Below is a list of the top and leading Bakeries in Indianapolis. To help you find the best Bakeries located near you in Indianapolis, we put together our own list based on this rating points list.

Indianapolis’s Best Bakeries: 

The top rated Bakeries in Indianapolis are:

  • Cretia Cakes Bake Shop – creates baked goods that s unique and different from other bakeries
  • Taylor’s Bakery – a family-operate and owned bakery specializing in the scratch recipe
  • Amelia’s – creates their products from scratch with a mix of modern technology.
  • BitterSweet – features numerous tasty baked goods prepared using the finest quality ingredients
  • The Flying Cupcake – offers beautifully designed tasty cakes and baked goods for the whole community

Cretia Cakes Bake Shop 

5 Best Bakeries in Indianapolis1

Cretia Cakes Bake Shop creates baked goods that s unique and different from other bakeries. They have various baked goods of all types and colors. Furthermore, some of their featured collection includes cookies and truffles. There are American wedding cookies, chocolate trifles, and cookie sandwiches. Their collection list consists of traditional cookies, southern baked goods, and some specialty products. The goods are made from the finest ingredients. It is designed so well up to the last detail. Cakes also fill their displays with intricate designs and delicious taste.

Products/ Services:

bakeries, cake, baked goods


Address: 6066 E 82nd St, Indianapolis, IN 46250
Phone: (317)-929-1560
Website: cretiacakes.com


“LaCretia did an incredible job on my cake. Not only did it look EXACTLY as I wanted but it also tasted amazing. I will definitely be going to LaCretia again for any future cake needs!” – Ayekke Player

Taylor’s Bakery

5 Best Bakeries in Indianapolis2

Taylor’s Bakery is a family-operate and owned bakery specializing in the scratch recipe. they create masterpieces like wedding cakes, birthday cakes, and specialty cakes. Their designs are unique and aesthetic. Furthermore, their product since cupcakes, cookies, and donuts. They have holiday-themed and scanned image designs for their cookies and cupcakes. Traditional cookies are also made using oatmeal, chocolate, and raisin. There are assorted yeast and cake doughnuts available. Moreover, they have ice cream and dinner rolls. Caramela and cheese popcorn is also available.

Products/ Services:

bakery, cake, cookies


Address:  6216 Allisonville Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46220
Phone: (317)-251-9575
Website: taylorsbakery.com


”Absolutely fantastic! Grew up in Fishers and never had a chance to go, but was up seeing my parents from Greenwood and stopped in. Got some of the cheesecake and lemon bars, the small canolis and an eclair. Fantastic!!” –  Ahsley Richardson


5 Best Bakeries in Indianapolis3

Amelia’s creates their products from scratch with a mix of modern technology. The products are made as early as 4 in the morning. The bakers and mixers prepare hundreds of sourdough loaves. It is then processed and hearth-baked. As it reached the perfect caramelization, it is then sold fresh. Furthermore, accept wholesale and retail orders. They have some featured products for various holidays and celebrations. Moreover, they handcraft the pieces of bread and pastries using European recipes. Their years of serving the community and their methods to perfect their products.

Products/ Services:

bakery, hand-craft, bread, pastry


Address: 653 Virginia Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46203
Phone: (317)-686-1583
Website:   ameliasbread.com


“Amazing bakery! I’ve never been disappointed by anything I’ve tried here! The bread, pastries, and cookies are all delightful! Truly feels like you’re eating from a bakery in Europe. They also have a nice assortment of grocery items, including local produce.” –  Sarah W.


5 Best Bakeries in Indianapolis4

BitterSweet features numerous tasty baked goods prepared using the finest quality ingredients. It is also made from scratch. They ell cakes by slice and various flavors daily. there are lemon bars, pecan bars, and cookie cakes. Hige cinnamon rolls e served every weekend. Furthermore, their classic cakes range from 6 to 10-inches in diameter. It is also their layers and can serve up to 30 people. Some flavors include lemon, confetti, and chocolate. Moreover, they have specialty cakes like coconut custard cake, german chocolate cake, and carrot cake. Some of their desserts are millionaire bars, apple doodle bars, and triple chocolate brownies.

Products/ Services:

bakery, specialty cakes, classic cake, dessert


Address:  5545 E Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46219
Phone: (317)-602-8665
Website:   bittersweetindy.com


”My favorite new irvington sweat stops! Cut cakes tender moist melt in your mouth. Generally friendly staff. Artistic and groundbreaking pastry chef.” – Derrek Alexander

The Flying Cupcake 

5 Best Bakeries in Indianapolis5

The Flying Cupcake offers beautifully designed tasty cakes and baked goods for the whole community. They have various products to choose from. Furthermore, they have cupcakes with classic flavors. it comes in mini, regular, and jumbo sizes. They also accept custom cupcake decorations. There are also gluten-free and vegan cupcakes. They accept pre-orders for gluten-free and vegan cupcakes. Moreover, they have round cakes with custom decorations. Clients may provide their preferred designs and they will completely follow them. They ensure that their clients are satisfied with the cake designs.

Products/ Services:

bakery, cake, cupcake


Address: 423 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Phone:  (317)-396-2696
Website:  theflyingcupcakebakery.com


“Huge, amazing cupcakes! You’ll be glad you went. Good luck deciding! We usually get several and we all share them to try new flavors. They are the BEST.” – Stacy Rumsey