Below is a list of the top and leading Bakeries in Columbus. To help you find the best Bakeries located near you in Columbus, we put together our own list based on this rating points list.
Columbus’ Best Bakeries:
The top rated Bakeries in Columbus are:
- Ohio Pies – is an authorized home bakery offering pies made from scratch
- Belle’s Bread Japanese Bakery & Café – is a family-owned bakery offering French-inspired Japanese baked goods
- A Blessed Cookie Co – starts by using only the best quality, all-natural ingredients
- Fate Cakes – provides a range of catering services
- Bake Me Happy – takes gluten-free very seriously
Ohio Pies is an authorized home bakery offering pies made from scratch with locally sourced and organic ingredients. Ohio Pies’ owner and baker, Emily Irvine began in 2006 when he was living abroad, missing my grandparents’ berry pies. He is driven by the desire to make people happy with pies that are the best they can possibly be, with flaky, buttery crusts and fillings that are bursting with flavor.
He chooses organic whenever possible because he does not want harmful chemical residue in my pies. Equally as important, he wants to support farmers who do not expose their workers to toxic chemicals, and who are using practices that don’t endanger the environment. Most of my packaging is biodegradable. He is continuing to look for better packaging solutions and eliminate all plastic products to create the smallest environmental footprint possible with my business.
By Slice Pie, Mini Pie, Hand Pie
Phone: (614) 440-5454
“Today we bought Strawberry Rhubarb pie at the German Village Makers Market and it was out of this world! The crust was light and flaky with ample fruit and just the right balance of the sweetness and sour of the strawberries and rhubarb. Well done. Bravo! Look forward to trying other standard and creative flavors! Emily may just be the ‘Jeni’ of the pie world.” – Rebecca P.
Belle’s Bread Japanese Bakery & Café
Belle’s Bread Japanese Bakery & Café is a family-owned bakery offering French-inspired Japanese baked goods. Owner Takashi Takenaka immigrated from Japan in 1972 and opened Restaurant Japan in 1987. Belle’s Bread was the 6th store added to the knotty and finishes the Japanese shopping center. With his French wife managing the accounting and his daughter running the bakery, it is truly a family affair.
They carry a large variety of products ranging from authentic French croissants and danishes to Japanese favorites. Their cakes are lightly sweet, moist, and natural tasting, typical of the Japanese style. Everything is baked domestically and fresh every day by their team of 20 bakers. They strive to use the best ingredients available because their customers’ health is of utmost importance to them.
Cakes, Bread, Drinks, Confections, Cold Treats
“Outstanding! My husband and I have been looking for a Japanese bakery in Columbus for the last three months and boy am I glad we found Belle’s Bread. Every one of their pastries looked absolutely perfect and delicious. They had both sweet and savory options and the flavors were so well balanced. The workers were kind and the displays were beautiful. This is definitely our new favorite spot in Columbus!” – Meowlory C.
A Blessed Cookie Co
A Blessed Cookie Co starts by using only the best quality, all-natural ingredients, and no preservatives. All of their cookies are made from scratch and baked fresh daily at their bakery to always deliver to you cookies with an irresistible fresh from the oven flavor. Offers exceptional quality with a homemade taste. The real experience of a home that has served Columbus for over 30 years. Every cookie is made with all-natural ingredients and assured to be the best cookie that you’ve ever tasted.
Cookie Store, Delivery, Shipping Options
“Ms. Dee is the kindest person in the world, the entire staff is friendly and accommodating. Nice variety of fresh-baked cookies, coffee is always fresh and a nice variety. A daily visit for me. Busy at times but your patience is rewarded. Coffee is always fresh as well as the assortment of baked goods, always a hello and a smile coming in the door. You will not regret the stop in, if only for the smell of the just-baked cookies.” – Randy W.
Fate Cakes provides a range of catering services including but not limited to weddings, bridal showers, baby showers, and graduations. You won’t have to lift a finger, let them do all the work. Highlighted as a Columbus, Ohio cupcake bakery, Fate Cakes is eager to introduce a website devoted to bringing you fun and tasty cupcakes, cakes, cookies, and all things sweet. They also make personalized OSU cupcakes for graduations, parties, or tailgating.
The best way to experience their wide collection of sweets is to visit the store. Follow the aromas and select the most alluring sweets to satisfy your palate. All their products are available for direct delivery in Columbus, Ohio and there are even options for next-day delivery services. They deliver to any doorway in Columbus or surrounding cities, commercial or residential. Astound that special someone with a personalized treat they won’t forget.
Weddings, Birthdays, Baby Showers, Bridal Showers, Graduations, Special Occasions
“Great customer service, answered inquiry quickly, pleasant to deal with. Made it possible for me to pick want I wanted without a problem and provided a pickup date and time satisfactory to my schedule as well. It was the best Coconut Cake I had in 15 years. Moist, well decorated, and icing that did not stick to the roof of my mouth. I ate 2 pieces right away. I took pictures but my phone would not act right. I sent them to Fate Cakes because she deserves excellent accolades.” – Yvonne J.
Bake Me Happy
Bake Me Happy takes gluten-free very seriously. Their brand new 2800 square foot space is now open in Merion Village. They do not allow any gluten-containing ingredients in their kitchen and they work very hard to keep everything safe for people with other allergies as well. Obviously, every item in the Bake Me Happy kitchen is gluten-free, but they are also proud consumers of a number of exceptional ingredients that are not only locally sourced but also the very best available anywhere.
For them, it’s not enough to make a passable gluten-free substitute, they would rather create something that everyone in the house, office, or restaurant, or at the party will enjoy. They love spreading the love, and they will always go the extra mile to bring people together and make them feel special.
Gluten-Free Desserts, Takeaway, Online Store
“Love this place best gluten free bakery in Columbus. Also since covid they offer grocery items that are hard to find. Plus the sonny Marie breads are my fav.” – Tanishia H.
Shera Elliott graduated from the New Mexico State University with a major in biology and a minor in Biological Basis of Behavior & Health Care Management. Shera grew up in Los Angeles, but moved to Las Cruces for college. Shera has written for several major publications including the Albuquerque Journal and NPR. Shera is a community reporter and also covers stories important important to all Americans.