Below is a list of the top and leading Bagel Shops in Columbus. To help you find the best Bagels located near you in Columbus, we put together our own list based on this rating points list.
Columbus’s Best Bagel Shops:
The top rated Bagel Shops in Columbus are:
- The Lox Bagel Shop – features hand-rolled, baked, and boiled bagels ad sandwiches
- Bruegger’s Bagels – serves authentic New York-style bagels to various locations across the country
- Einstein Bros. Bagels – serves gourmet bagels that are freshly baked daily paired with their best-tasting drinks
- Barry Bagels Westerville – offers more than a dozen of bagel varieties for over 40 years
- Broad Street Bagels and Deli – feature an array of sandwiches, bagels, and salads in a homey and comforting restaurant
The Lox Bagel Shop
The Lox Bagel Shop features hand-rolled, baked, and boiled bagels ad sandwiches. Their bagels are a fusion of Montreal and New York- style of preparation. Their products are boiled and fried in a live-fire oven. Moreover, they source their ingredients from trusted markets. They choose only the best to become part of their product preparation. Furthermore, their bagel variations include plain, sea salt and herb, and sesame. There are cream cheese variations, jam, and fancy jam for spreads. They also serve beverages including iced coffee, bloody mary, and mimosa.
bagel shops, bagel sandwich
Address: 772 N High St #106, Columbus, OH 43215
”DELICIOUS! The sea salt and herb bagel was to die for and I loved the vegan cream cheese. My dairy allergy has really takes the enjoyment out of bagels for me…but this vegan cream cheese definitely hit the spot. Can’t wait to try one of their bagel sandwiches.” – Anna Payne
Bruegger’s Bagels serves authentic New York-style bagels to various locations across the country. They directly learned from experts in New York on the traditional methods of bagel-making. There are dozens of blends for cream cheese. They also have a wide variation of spreads for all bagels. Moreover, they have vegetarian and seasonal bagels available on their menu. their bagels menu includes whole wheat, cinnamon sugar, and Jalapeno cheddar. Their cream cheese blends include plain, garden veggie, and bacon scallion. There are also family meals like a chocolate chip cookie kit, smoked salmon plate, and a brunch box filled with bagels.
bagel shop, cream cheese
Address: 1630 Neil Ave, Columbus, OH 43201
“Speedy and friendly service! Their bagels are truly delicious!!” – Maddie Angle
Einstein Bros. Bagels
Einstein Bros. Bagels serves gourmet bagels that are freshly baked daily paired with their best-tasting drinks. There are signature egg sandwiches and lunch sandwiches available. They also accept requests for catering on all types of occasions. Furtehmore, their bagel menu covers jalapeno cheddar, avocado toast, and apple cinnamon. The chocolate chip, cinnamon sugar, and French toast are part of their signature bagels. Moreover, their family meals include a pizza bagel kit, brunch box, and family pizza bagel box. They serve a wide range of hot and cold drinks including caramel macchiato, chai tea latte, and vanilla sweet cream cold brew.
bagel shop, bagel sandwich, coffee, tea, family meals
Address: 41 S High St, Columbus, OH 43215
”I always love Einstein bagels. This restaurant is great for several times of day such as your daily coffee before work, mid morning brunch with breakfast items, and lunch & dinner. They have delicious options for each. They also offer large quantities of bagels, but make sure to go early in the day before they’re sold out. Here, you can get high quality food.” – Jason Williams
Barry Bagels Westerville
Barry Bagels Westerville offers more than a dozen of bagel varieties for over 40 years. They have their own selection of flavored cream cheese and spreads. Their products provide inspiration to entrepreneurs through franchising. Furthermore, they have a wide range of products made with the best ingredients. Their bagel variations include onion everything, pumpernickel, and sunny grain. There are also eggel variations with cheese and meat. Moreover, their selections of sandwiches include chicken salad, bagel dog, cheese, and hot corned beef. They also serve gourmet coffee in short and grande sizes.
bagel shops, coffee, sandwiches
Address: 655 Worthington Rd, Westerville, OH 43082
”I’ve always had a positive experience at J.O.! They are such wonderful and caring people who truly execute strategic public relations and marketing for a variety of unique clients! Also, do I need to mention that they have a swing?!” – Tanya Lariviere
Broad Street Bagels and Deli
Broad Street Bagels and Deli feature an array of sandwiches, bagels, and salads in a homey and comforting restaurant. Their staff provides excellent customer service and welcomes guests warmly. They serve breakfast meals like a bagel with cream cheese, breakfast burrito, and dry bagel. Furthermore, they serve eggs on toast or bagel and homestyle sandwiches. Their sandwich selection includes chicken cordon blue, smoked turkey club melt, and veggies. Moreover, they serve wraps like gyro, Asian chicken, and turkey bacon guacamole. They have Stauf’s coffee with variations like house decaf, highlander grog, and house blend.
bagel shops, coffee, sandwich
Address: 66 E Broad St, Columbus, OH 43215
”Great prices and welcoming staff! Decided to try something different and ordered the Honey Club Wrap which was incredible.” – Brittany Smith